Editorial Conversation: AMA #8 (Sheng, Shou, and Menghai)
Thank you to everyone who joined us for our Eighth AMA with the editorial team! You can listen to the episode here, on YouTube, or on Spotify. We kick off this AMA with light banter on recent music, reading, and shows before diving into the a more serious discussion on our challenges in writing the Menghai trip reports, the best teas we tasted on this research trip, common misconceptions about puer processing, debates about danzhu, boutique vs. traditional shou fermentation, and bigger-picture concerns like climate change and tea commentary culture.
A full transcript is included below:
[00:00:05] Jason Cohen: Thank you, everyone, for joining us in Tea Technique Editorial Conversations, AMA. This one, I assume, focused on our trip reports to Menghai.
[00:00:15] Pat Penny: No, we're gonna go all over the place. So, as per usual, yep, let's go right to something we haven't written anything about.
As per usual we're gonna start with some softballs, Jason. We'll go to questions that were submitted to me via Instagram, any questions you got via email or via the website, and then of course at any point, live questions we'll continue to answer.
So, I went back and just listened through some of our old AMAs. We answer a lot of the same opener questions, which is like, what have you been doing differently recently with tea? What's, what's your practice? Yeah, what are you drinking?
We're gonna touch what are you drinking, 'cause I know you've probably poured something expensive and you wanna talk about it. So if, you wanna go ahead, you can start with that. But then we're gonna do some different opener questions that I've kind of taken a tangent from some of the submitted questions to do.
[00:01:04] Jason Cohen: What am I drinking? Do you wanna go first? You're just, you're the-
[00:01:06] Pat Penny: I just feel like you'd feel bad if you didn't get to tell anyone what you were drinking, but,
[00:01:09] Jason Cohen: I, would feel bad. This is... Go, ahead.
[00:01:11] Pat Penny: Okay. Well, I kind of caveated it in the trip report that I wrote. What am I drinking for the rest of 2026 after visiting Menghai?
This is Yiwu sheng puer. So, I did actually have a moment where I had a little bit of an identity crisis and I was looking in my pumidor and I was like, "I think I'm gonna drink some pasha." We had a pasha cake we commissioned on the trip. It was delicious. I've been reaching for it a lot. We only have one cake each actually, so it's been painful to reach for it, but I was going for that. And I don't know what happened. I like blacked out and I came out with a Mahei cake from Yiwu, so.
[00:01:46] Jason Cohen: No way, man. I am, I'm hoarding that. I love that pasha cake, but I am hoarding that. I've had it twice and I think it's going in storage for over a year-
[00:01:53] Pat Penny: Yeah, yeah
[00:01:53] Jason Cohen: Before I touch that again.
[00:01:54] Pat Penny: It tastes amazing.
Now on to you. What are you drinking?
[00:01:57] Jason Cohen: Now on to me. Well, some of you know, this is a, kind of a bittersweet special moment. This is the last AMA that I'm doing in this room. After a decade here, I have given up this lease to do a little bit of a, an adventure. So I'm excited. It's a big thing, but I'm doing this AMA tonight. I'm doing a Talk Taste Triage tomorrow and then I start tearing this place down.
So in, in commemoration, I grabbed one of my favorite special, not tea beverages. This is a 2008 distillery exclusive Glenfarclas. Glenfarclas has always been my favorite whiskey distillery. And I picked this one up at the distillery and it's just a, it's a really special, unique bottle. So, I'm loving it. I'm sitting here drinking a dram. So my answers will get less and less eloquent as this AMA goes on.
[00:02:52] Pat Penny: Or more.
[00:02:53] Jason Cohen: Or more. Cheers, Pat.
[00:02:54] Pat Penny: Cheers. I think you poured that same dram for us over New Year's, so if I remember correctly, and it was delicious. I, I do think you broke that one out.
[00:03:03] Jason Cohen: I think I did. I think I did.
[00:03:04] Pat Penny: Yeah. It was Glen Grant, like a early '90s, and then I think we had that on the second night. So definitely special drink.
[00:03:11] Jason Cohen: That was also the bottle I almost reached for, 1990s Glen Grant.
[00:03:14] Pat Penny: I know your favorites. Do you wanna tell the audience about what you're doing after you break down this apartment and what your plans are? I don't know if you've shared on the podcast.
[00:03:23] Jason Cohen: I don't think we've shared. I'm going to be spending a whole lot of time in China. I'm gonna be moving to China for a little while and doing a bunch of tea related things, but also just living life over there. And, I, I've been going to China for 19 years pretty regularly. Minus the COVID years, I've been there almost every year for 19 years with a couple of gaps. And, I'm always there either on, on tea work or on business. And it's finally a chance. I haven't really spent huge amounts of time, just unscheduled time there since really like 2007, 2009. Everything after that has been go, go, go.
And so this is a chance to go and actually live there and not just be go, go, go all the time. Although Pat knows how I travel, so we'll see how well that plan works. But yeah, I'm gonna, I'm gonna be following the harvest through Yunnan, through Xishuangbanna. I'm gonna be doing a couple of things in Wuyi. I'll be visiting friends all over the place, and then we're just gonna spend a little bit of time in a few places that are not 100% tea related. And,
[00:04:33] Pat Penny: Only a tiny bit of time in those spots.
[00:04:36] Jason Cohen: Yeah. I mean, we'll go to like Hangzhou and like I'll just go to Xi Hu (West Lake) every day. Just the spots that aren't 100% tea.
[00:04:44] Pat Penny: Yeah, 95. I- There's some good coffee shops in Hangzhou, actually, so you know.
[00:04:48] Jason Cohen: Some great coffee in Hangzhou.
[00:04:49] Pat Penny: Little coffee by morning or maybe midday. Tea in the morning, go up to the farms. So there's some good options. But yeah, I mean, that's really exciting. I would say that like I'm upset that you're moving further away, but I actually only really see you in China, so I'll just see you in China again next year.
[00:05:05] Jason Cohen: Is it further away, Pat? I don't know. You get your direct Seattle flight to, to Hangzhou.
[00:05:09] Pat Penny: That's true. It's probably technically a little further mileage-wise, and, and time-wise, actually, it's harder to coordinate with you. But I'm, I'm excited for you. I'm excited for you to be in China a little bit more permanently. I'm very excited for your Chinese to get better. Not that we struggle on trips, 'cause I think we do pretty decently, but I'm ready for you to speak the way you do in English to all of our contacts in Mandarin.
[00:05:31] Jason Cohen: Super eloquent. Super eloquent.
[00:05:32] Pat Penny: Yeah. Or Yunnanese. You can develop some ratchet Yunnanese slang.
[00:05:35] Jason Cohen: Yeah. I gotta get my I gotta get my Yunnan slang going.
[00:05:38] Pat Penny: That would be sick.
[00:05:39] Jason Cohen: Yeah. And you know what I'm excited about? I'm excited to be able to talk about something other than tea in Chinese.
[00:05:44] Pat Penny: No, no. Don't even go there. Don't even... Don't bother. Don't bother.
[00:05:49] Jason Cohen: The rest of my language skills.
[00:05:52] Pat Penny: I'd like you to just continue pigeonholing your language ability to strictly tea.
[00:05:57] Jason Cohen: I did pretty well on Buddhism. We got into that conversation on Buddhist, on Dai Buddhism.
[00:06:03] Pat Penny: I didn't believe it until it was translated, but yes. I thought... I mean, I understand a little bit, right, of what you're saying in Mandarin, and I definitely thought that you were just going off on a tangent and no one understood you. It turned out that everyone understood what you were talking about. I just had no context. Which, our audience right now probably has no context to.
So, I have some just questions from me, and then we'll hop into actual listener-submitted questions. So, just to kinda casually break into things, what's been your recent binge watch, binge read or listen? So, in the trip report you had dropped some great listening recommendations like Mistakes on Purpose, which I hopped onto and have been listening to a lot of. But any of your other recos that I need to take up?
[00:06:46] Jason Cohen: Oh, wow. I'm so glad you like that. Your music preferences have been converging in surprising ways on some of my preferences.
[00:06:54] Pat Penny: Well, you're not listening to any of my, like, Swedish tech death or anything like that, which is disappointing to me, but it's okay.
[00:07:00] Jason Cohen: That's... That's what I'm saying. This seems like a, a one-way flow. I, I love that album, Mistakes on Purpose. I love all of the Ethiopian jazz and then the Pan-African jazz funk that we've been going off on for a while. I think I mentioned this on the last AMA with Max. I, I've been on, like, a Jamaican dancehall dub kick. I'm just real into that, that loud bass Jamaican dancehall dub. I know I look the part for that. But yeah, I've been really digging that.
And then unbelievably, just recently, I discovered some good, what they're calling modern mixes of traditional Chinese music. Generally not big into Chinese music. I love everything about China, but musical qualities have thus far been lacking with the exception of, like, 1920s Shanghai jazz. And there's, of course, Shanghai Restoration Project that did the, the recreations of the, that golden era of Shanghai jazz. But I just recently discovered a couple of other albums where they actually took the original recordings and remixed them into, like, a downbeat super lounge. They've been kinda awesome.
[00:08:12] Pat Penny: Send them over 'cause I- ... usually, I feel like you talk about music you're listening to, and I'm like, "That sounds like nothing I'm gonna enjoy at all." But then I listen to it and then, it grows on me pretty quickly usually. So send something over. Was there a, a, a book or a, a binge watch to go along with that?
[00:08:32] Jason Cohen: Ooh, binge watch. Well, I am struggling my way through some Chinese TV show. I don't actually recommend the Chinese TV show. I'm just watching this to get used to non-tea conversation, and it's also helpful that they have a northern dialect and stuff, and they're using real contemporary young woman language, using all sorts of vocabulary I don't know.
[00:09:01] Pat Penny: We only know, like, the really old people language.
[00:09:03] Jason Cohen: We know the farmer language.
[00:09:04] Pat Penny: It's all tea farmers. Yeah.
[00:09:05] Jason Cohen: Yeah, all tea farmer language. So I've been struggling my way through watching a, a Chinese TV show. That's been taking up my watch time.
Reading. Reading. What am I reading right now? Oh, The Other Great Game. It's all about the... the Great Game is usually a, a reference to the mid to early 1800s intercenary wars in between the European states. And so someone took this, not Clausewitz, but one of these other great political thinkers, wartime thinkers, and applied his theory to the colonization of Korea between Japan, Russia, Britain, France, Germany, United States, and the way that Korea was used as a stepping stone into control over parts of Asian maritime trade.
And the book is just phenomenal. Yeah, 10 out of 10, no notes. Just phenomenal book.
[00:10:00] Pat Penny: Like most things you read, it doesn't sound like light reading. Kinda hopping over to myself with light reading. I'm reading Brandon Sanderson's fifth Stormlight Archive book, which is the the last for this arc. It kicks off just fast, intense, good. Just if you need pure high fantasy or if you've ever read Sanderson and you haven't read the Stormlight Archive, I would highly recommend it. Jason, I know you really haven't read a lot of Sanderson, but if you were going to start anywhere, I would recommend this series of books.
So, Stormlight Archive. I'm on the last of the five. They are not short books, but they're easy reads.
[00:10:36] Jason Cohen: Okay
[00:10:36] Pat Penny: ... So you know, 1,000 to 1,400 pages, but it's, it's almost candy. Like, you can read through it really quick. And I had actually just read all eight of the currently available Dungeon Crawler Carl books in the last two months, so that's real book candy. I mean, those things you can just pick up, put down, blast through them. So it's been a lot of fiction for me this year.
[00:11:00] Jason Cohen: That's great.
[00:11:00] Pat Penny: Exclusively, really.
On the music side, we have a, you know, guest in the chat that dropped some Chinese shoegaze, which I'm definitely interested in. It's been getting recommended to me on my Instagram algorithm a lot recently for some reason, but I haven't really-
[00:11:13] Jason Cohen: Oh, really?
[00:11:13] Pat Penny: ... dived in. Well, I do listen to some shoegaze too, but Japanese shoegaze like Toe has been more my, my go-tos. But,
[00:11:20] Jason Cohen: Not Shou? Are you sure?
[00:11:21] Pat Penny: No, not Shou. It's Tow.
[00:11:23] Jason Cohen: Tow
[00:11:23] Pat Penny: But, I've been listening to actually mostly a lot of metal, so it's been... there's a thing called MySpace deathcore revival. It's basically like the deathcore of the 2006 to 2010 era but with polished sound now. It's a big thing in the metal scene the past couple months, so that's been what I've mostly been doing.
Interesting artist that's not totally metal that maybe people could check out is an artist called Ando San. It's still kind of metal but, like, gangster rap meets metal, but with really cool thumping guitars, really cool guitar work. Cool, like, lyricism, but a a little bit dipping its toe in both worlds of, like, rap and metal, but really well done.
[00:12:04] Jason Cohen: This is like the Jay-Z, Linkin Park.
[00:12:07] Pat Penny: It actually does sound like it could be on the Need for Speed soundtrack. So yeah,
[00:12:11] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[00:12:11] Pat Penny: ... It does give that.
[00:12:12] Jason Cohen: I, I love that album. That's a great album. I recommend that.
[00:12:14] Pat Penny: It's in the best way, in the best way. It's, it's got, little bit of that nu metal vibe, so.
[00:12:19] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[00:12:19] Pat Penny: Worth a listen. I on shows, Sam and I binge-watched the first season of Heroes, 'cause I had never watched it. It came out nearly two decades ago. If you haven't seen it, okay, it's, it was like a network television show back in maybe 2008 or 2009. But it was actually really good. Supposedly it goes super downhill after season one, so we just stopped right there. But totally entertaining. It's got a lot of pitfalls of the mid-2000s TV. The budget's definitely not high. But totally enjoyable.
So I like that everything that you listed was of a kind of certain highbrow, and I feel like everything I've listed is of a certain lowbrow- which just kinda fits, I think, the theme of the trip reports we did and everything else, so. Yeah, just keeping it classy over there, Jason.
[00:13:08] Jason Cohen: That, that book only has like 200 pages of citations. So
[00:13:12] Pat Penny: I thought you were just gonna stop at pages, and I was like, "Oh, that is pretty short, but it sounds pretty dense."
[00:13:16] Jason Cohen: No, no, it's, it's 800 pages of content and 200 pages of citations.
[00:13:21] Pat Penny: Hm. Only a little shorter than Stormlight Archive.
[00:13:25] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[00:13:26] Pat Penny: But also probably infinitely more dense.
We can kick into the actual questions I got on Instagram if you're ready.
[00:13:32] Jason Cohen: I think we should. I think we should.
[00:13:33] Pat Penny: Okay. Okay. And once again, anyone who's joining us live your questions are prioritized, so feel free to drop things in. We did get a question, I think because of how much food content I posted and how much I talked about donkey, what was our most memorable meal of the trip? Maybe we'll not talk about donkey, 'cause it was memorable like in a bad way, and I think we've talked about it enough.
[00:13:54] Jason Cohen: Well, I summoned something. Well, really you summoned something. We together summoned something that you know just had to appear.
[00:14:04] Pat Penny: Talk about it.
[00:14:05] Jason Cohen: But dick soup
[00:14:09] Pat Penny: Keep going. Keep going.
[00:14:10] Jason Cohen: That is that... I mentioned this to Pat. Pat I sent an article, a very good Fuchsia Dunlop article, to Pat just because I thought he'd like the content and recipe. And Pat then proceeds to talk about it through the, throughout-
[00:14:25] Pat Penny: I think it was our pre-trip, our pre-trip AMA.
[00:14:27] Jason Cohen: Yeah, on the pre-trip? Yeah. Or was it the one with, was it the one with Max?
[00:14:32] Pat Penny: Might've been with Max, yeah.
[00:14:33] Jason Cohen: I think it was with Max.
[00:14:34] Pat Penny: But we, we talked about ... we talked about dick soup live on air.
[00:14:36] Jason Cohen: Yeah. We talked about it, and then of course we get to Menghai and we go into the furthest, farthest reaches of Hua Zhu Liang Zi (滑竹梁子) .
[00:14:45] Pat Penny: Yep.
[00:14:46] Jason Cohen: And as deep in the mountains as you can be, and we get stuck there drinking with one of the, the farmers. Awesome-
[00:14:53] Pat Penny: Stuck is a really good word ...
[00:14:55] Jason Cohen: Awesome guy.
[00:14:55] Pat Penny: Stuck is a great word.
[00:14:56] Jason Cohen: Awesome guy. Yeah. But we were so stuck. We were so unhappy to still be there. For a variety of reasons.
[00:15:01] Pat Penny: Yeah.
[00:15:02] Jason Cohen: But great guy. It was, everything was fine, and this guy was literally single-handing a, what had to be, like, an eight-liter if not 10-liter kettle of boiling water-
[00:15:15] Pat Penny: It was so much bigger than that ...
[00:15:17] Jason Cohen: straight off of fire. You think it was, like, 15, 15?
[00:15:20] Pat Penny: Dude, 10, 10 liters is just two gallons.
That was, like, a four gallon, five gallon-
[00:15:25] Jason Cohen: That was, that was, like, four or five gallons. You're right.
[00:15:27] Pat Penny: Yeah.
[00:15:27] Jason Cohen: That was, like, four or five gallons. That was, like, four or five gallons, and this guy is single-arming it full on boil and just putting it in between all of the dinner table guests. And this thing is, like, glowing hot straight out of the fire. Someone else tried to lift it and could barely lift it.
I, I think it was, one of our hosts was playing around doing it, and then they had me try to lift it, too. And I could lift it just fine, but I could tell you I would not be able to pour it with the accuracy that he had poured it with. It was heavy. It was sloshing. Man anyway, this guy-
[00:15:57] Pat Penny: There was a child walking around, like-
[00:15:59] Jason Cohen: This, this guy- ...
[00:16:00] Pat Penny: with this kettle out ...
[00:16:01] Jason Cohen: this guy had hunted a wild muntjac deer. And he said his wife was with relatives or something, and so he had to do the cooking and- great hunted deer.
He did the cooking and maybe he saved the best parts for his esteemed foreign guests because we got the penis soup.
[00:16:22] Pat Penny: Yeah. We also had I don't know if this was a different animal. There was cow, right? We had the cow vagina congee.
[00:16:28] Jason Cohen: We had
[00:16:29] Pat Penny: the- In the same meal.
[00:16:29] Jason Cohen: Oh, yes. We had the cow vagina congee.
[00:16:31] Pat Penny: So, so we had cow vagina and deer or muntjac dick all in one meal.
[00:16:37] Jason Cohen: Oh, yum.
[00:16:37] Pat Penny: So it really was a very special meal. When we were eating, like literally seconds into eating, one of our other kind of hosts who was taking us around, who had known this farmer like almost immediately commented that this guy was not a good cook, like out loud.
It's one of the first things she said when we sat down to eat.
[00:16:54] Jason Cohen: It, like the ingredients were fine. The cooking was just uninspired. There-
[00:16:58] Pat Penny: But o- once again, like super gracious for hosting us. But it was I think maybe another memorable bad meal.
[00:17:06] Jason Cohen: It wasn't great. It wasn't bad like spit it out bad.
[00:17:09] Pat Penny: Mm-hmm.
[00:17:10] Jason Cohen: It was just very plain. And I'm not squeamish, I don't care. It's cow vagina congee-
[00:17:16] Pat Penny: It was all cooked.
It was all cooked ...
[00:17:17] Jason Cohen: dick soup. It was like I don't care. I don't get squeamish about that stuff. But, I don't know what that guy was trying to pull because if these things were aphrodisiacs, we were getting like we were leaving that mountain that night.
[00:17:28] Pat Penny: Just all of us dudes in that car-
[00:17:30] Jason Cohen: All of us dudes
[00:17:31] Pat Penny: driving back. That was the same day that we ate donkey.
[00:17:35] Jason Cohen: It was.
[00:17:36] Pat Penny: Right? So we-
[00:17:36] Jason Cohen: It was a very special day.
[00:17:38] Pat Penny: We ate the donkey for lunch. This was, we were probably still hungover from shaokao the night before and-
[00:17:45] Jason Cohen: Yeah
[00:17:45] Pat Penny: ... bad baijiu. We eat the donkey. We get on like a three-hour car ride through like, Na Ka and making our way to Hua Zhu Liang Zi. We were like so nauseous multiple times in that car, and then they feed us dick and vagina stews of sorts for us to just take the car ride in the dark back down, which luckily was like only an hour and a half I think on the way back, like an hour and a half, two hours.
[00:18:10] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[00:18:10] Pat Penny: But yeah, it was, those were rough car rides after those meals.
[00:18:14] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[00:18:14] Pat Penny: I wanna say that my most memorable meal was not that. I think that's when I wanted to like black out. Once again, not 'cause it was so bad, it was just like we, we were very much trapped there. I think my most memorable positive meal was the food that we had had the last night before I went back.
We were in Jinghong. I don't remember the name of the cuisine. Was it Shandong? It wasn't Shandong, right?
[00:18:36] Jason Cohen: Yeah. It was from Northern Myanmar on the people who overlap into Xishuangbanna from the northern hill tribes.
[00:18:43] Pat Penny: So it was quite like spicy, very flavorful. Just so different than everything we had been eating in the mountains, right? Like really packed with flavor.
[00:18:52] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[00:18:52] Pat Penny: And that was awesome. It was memorable because it was super spicy, and I was flying out the next day, so it really stayed with me.
[00:19:00] Jason Cohen: People are always trying to do that to you, Pat.
[00:19:02] Pat Penny: You actually do always do it to me, but
[00:19:03] Jason Cohen: We, we always have your best interest at heart ...
[00:19:06] Pat Penny: My flight when I landed in, so like I was flying from, I think I flew from Jinghong to Shanghai. And my flight as I'm landing was canceled from Shanghai to Seattle. So I'm just stuck in that airport for nine hours waiting for another flight with just my stomach in total turmoil from that food the night before.
Once again, it was still delicious. I would not make any changes, but it really stayed with me. That was a memorable eating experience.
[00:19:32] Jason Cohen: We're always picking the most questionable food for Pat's
[00:19:36] Pat Penny: My last night.
[00:19:37] Jason Cohen: Yeah, for Pat's last night.
[00:19:39] Pat Penny: I will say definitely still better than the raw marinated seafood in Chaozhou.
[00:19:44] Jason Cohen: I'm a fan. I'm a fan. I'd go back there.
[00:19:46] Pat Penny: I liked the flavor. I think I liked this food that we had this previous last night more. And I preferred the effects over what I had had from the previous night.
[00:19:55] Jason Cohen: You have a preference for the cooked food.
[00:19:56] Pat Penny: Yeah. We, we talk about all these foods that we eat though and kind of crazy eating experiences. We've only really gotten sick the one time in China. And, like-
[00:20:05] Jason Cohen: Yeah
[00:20:05] Pat Penny: ... only slightly sick with the Wuyi rat tartare so yeah. W- All things considered this past year we did do really well on food. No, no questionable things at all. Okay, I feel like we answered that one enough for-
[00:20:17] Jason Cohen: Yep
[00:20:17] Pat Penny: our listener. This was a fun one. So what hobby or interest do you have that would surprise most Tea Technique listeners?
[00:20:27] Jason Cohen: Do I have one, Pat?
[00:20:29] Pat Penny: You do more than just tea.
[00:20:31] Jason Cohen: Yeah, but what would be surprising? I think everyone knows I rock climb. I've been rock climbing for a long time. I think everyone knows that I build AI models that funds all of the, the tea stuff.
What do I do that's super surprising?
[00:20:45] Pat Penny: I don't know.
[00:20:46] Jason Cohen: You don't know? I-
[00:20:47] Pat Penny: It's just a question that we had submitted. We have to answer
it.
[00:20:49] Jason Cohen: I live the stereotype. Like, I got my sailing license, I ski, water-ski.
[00:20:58] Pat Penny: Do you collect anything other than tea-related paraphernalia?
[00:21:02] Jason Cohen: Wine.
[00:21:05] Pat Penny: You have a lot of hobbies, actually.
I guess they're just not surprising when people start to know you.
[00:21:11] Jason Cohen: No, I don't know. We got 100-something bottles of wine at home, and that's cut down by half before this move.
[00:21:20] Pat Penny: Yeah, if you need to ship any over to me for safekeeping, just feel free.
[00:21:23] Jason Cohen: Yeah, just well-labeled.
[00:21:26] Pat Penny: Just saying. Yeah. Yeah, like drink this, don't drink this. I'll listen.
[00:21:30] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[00:21:30] Pat Penny: Don't worry. Yeah.
[00:21:31] Jason Cohen: I don't know, I don't know what would be surprising. I don't feel like I have... for anyone who knows me, I don't know if I have any surprising hobbies.
[00:21:39] Pat Penny: Yeah, you're not really like a brain rot video gamer or anything like that. You're not playing Overwatch or League secretly.
[00:21:47] Jason Cohen: No, no.
[00:21:48] Pat Penny: No. No Netflix subscription so that you can watch Love Island.
[00:21:52] Jason Cohen: I don't have Netflix, no. I don't know what would be surprising.
[00:21:59] Pat Penny: You, you, I guess you're not surprising person.
[00:22:01] Jason Cohen: No.
[00:22:02] Pat Penny: I actually think of you as a person who's full of surprises, but, you just don't surprise me as much now because I've known you for this long.
And yeah, may- think, think on it. You can always answer it later, later in the conversation.
[00:22:13] Jason Cohen: Yeah, something, a flash of insight comes to me.
[00:22:15] Pat Penny: Do you have something that you think would surprise listeners for me?
[00:22:18] Jason Cohen: Do I have something that I would think surprise listeners for you?
That is so hard to, to go back to that realm of not knowing you. I mean, I think some of your music preferences are surprising. I think the metal music preference is surprising. Can we talk about your band? Is your band-
[00:22:36] Pat Penny: Oh, yeah. I guess that would be a surprising one.
[00:22:38] Jason Cohen: Yeah. That's surprising. I, well, we're, we're working on demos, but I'm I'm in, like, a sh- straight up death metal band. We don't have any music out yet, so de- demos forthcoming. When we do have some music, I will share everything through-
I'll, I'll link to it ...
[00:22:51] Pat Penny: through the podcast.
[00:22:51] Jason Cohen: I'll link to it.
[00:22:51] Pat Penny: Yeah. That's part,
[00:22:52] Jason Cohen: It'll be from Cult of Quality, not from Tea Technique.
[00:22:54] Pat Penny: Yeah. Not good tea listening music. But you know, I, I played drums, actually in a band for a while back in high school. But I'm switching to vocals for this, so I've been practicing extreme vocals for, like, I don't know, about 18 months now.
[00:23:09] Jason Cohen: Cool.
[00:23:09] Pat Penny: And yeah. I'm excited to do it. So, we'll see. But I guess that's probably the most unexpected hobby from a standard Tea Technique listener.
[00:23:16] Jason Cohen: It's hard to think of you as a singer.
[00:23:19] Pat Penny: I've, I mean, I was behind a drum kit for a long time, so me too. Yeah. But I'm excited to do it.
[00:23:24] Jason Cohen: Yeah. Well, I guess, maybe I have one. I don't know if this is the moment. For a long time we've been starting and kicking off these AMAs, which are much more casual, of course, than our editorial conversations with a song that I made-
[00:23:39] Pat Penny: Yeah
[00:23:39] Jason Cohen: ... or, or something else. We didn't do that this time, but I do have something-
[00:23:42] Pat Penny: I'm, I'm not disappointed, but yeah.
[00:23:44] Jason Cohen: No, I have something to share. I think, I feel like some of the music has become old hat and I needed to really step it up a notch. And so I, I do as, maybe this is a surprising side hobby, but for this creative act, I, I felt like we needed something for this AMA. And we did get a question about brain rot. Maybe you bring this up now and then I share this in response.
[00:24:07] Pat Penny: W- we did get a question on it, so I'll, I'll jump in here. This was how it was phrased. So eco-pilled high tea forest maxing soil supremacist, does Jason have brain rot? So I think this was in reference to your most recent post, your trip report. But J- Jason, do you have brain rot?
[00:24:25] Jason Cohen: Do I have brain rot? Fan, for real? Of course, I got brain rot. This is my sigma personality. Don't @ me. Please.
[00:24:36] Pat Penny: Don't worry, listeners, I too have no idea what's going on with Jason.
[00:24:39] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
Okay. All right. Let me share. Let me share. Let's see if this works. Share sound, video. Share.
[00:24:50] Pat Penny: Okay. Go for it.
Alright, it's was as cringey as, as every time that you share something.
[00:25:26] Jason Cohen: Oh, that's awesome.
[00:25:27] Pat Penny: Oh, no, It was good. It was definitely cringey, but it was good. Yeah, I mean, I, I-
[00:25:32] Jason Cohen: K-pop tea hunter, yes. Yes.
[00:25:35] Pat Penny: I, I vibe with it. I vibe with it. What was up with my hands in that?
[00:25:40] Jason Cohen: What do you mean?
[00:25:41] Pat Penny: My hands looked real weird in that. Did you, like, do the, the coding for it? Or how did you, did you just do some AI prompts? Like, what was up with that?
[00:25:50] Jason Cohen: No. I it's a, it's AI, obviously, but-
[00:25:53] Pat Penny: Yeah, yeah.
[00:25:54] Jason Cohen: Yeah. You can't just type in Jason and Pat dancing.
[00:25:58] Pat Penny: It got pretty accurate.
It's looking, looking pretty good.
[00:26:01] Jason Cohen: Yeah, you gotta-
[00:26:01] Pat Penny: Yeah ...
[00:26:02] Jason Cohen: you gotta do some real work to get that level of of detail.
[00:26:04] Pat Penny: I mean, I don't know how much the Tea Technique fan base loves AI. the whole tea community on a lot of the platforms aren't very pro-AI right now, but, it was a fun video.
[00:26:14] Jason Cohen: That's my surprising hobby.
[00:26:15] Pat Penny: I think that is a surprising hobby. When people know that you do, like, AI-related data work and things like that, it might be less surprising, but-
And if they've listened to the previous AMAs where you have your opening theme song, but yeah, yeah, it's still a surprising one.
[00:26:31] Jason Cohen: Yeah. Okay. Well, I think- All right ... I think we beat that question.
[00:26:34] Pat Penny: I think we can move on. This was just a weird, out of left field one so I wanted to put it in here. If you couldn't drink tea for a month, what would you drink instead?
[00:26:45] Jason Cohen: I mean, I do drink coffee, so I-
[00:26:49] Pat Penny: I know, but think about how much time you spend drinking tea. What would fill that gap?
[00:26:54] Jason Cohen: What would fill that gap? What would fill that gap?
[00:26:57] Pat Penny: That giant hole in your soul.
[00:26:59] Jason Cohen: Wine?
[00:27:02] Pat Penny: So you're gonna become a drunk?
[00:27:04] Jason Cohen: Yeah. Am I not already?
[00:27:07] Pat Penny: That's a good question. I, I'll let you answer that. I won't answer that for you.
[00:27:15] Jason Cohen: Okay.
[00:27:16] Pat Penny: But, I don't I, I would also probably just drink water, honestly. I have no idea what I would replace it with.
[00:27:22] Jason Cohen: No.
[00:27:24] Pat Penny: I, yeah, just gaping hole in my soul.
This is a live question. Thank you for submitting it. Where do both of you stand on astrology, Chinese or Western? Jason, you end up leveraging a lot more of the, the years on all our commissions and things like that, so maybe you can give your answer.
[00:27:43] Jason Cohen: Well, that's gangzhi versus the zodiac. But yeah, I do the sextogenary cycle which is one of the historical date keeping systems for scholarly Chinese works, and we have all of our ceramic commissions inscribed with gangzhi.
For a more, I think, closer to what you're asking about is probably astrological signs. I am a metal sheep in the Chinese system, and I think I'm first day of Pisces in the Western system. But couldn't tell you anything about either of those characteristics.
[00:28:20] Pat Penny: We're the same birth year, so I'm also a metal sheep. But I think it's also, like in some of the cycles, isn't that the restart of the 60-year cycle and it's also considered like the golden sheep or something like that?
[00:28:35] Jason Cohen: Oh, I don't know. Is it?
[00:28:36] Pat Penny: Okay. I would- I think it's like the resetting of the, the cycle, the sextogenary cycle, so I think it's also considered golden sheep.
[00:28:43] Jason Cohen: Oh, man. No wonder I'm so lucky.
[00:28:44] Pat Penny: Which, yeah, we're pretty sick like that.
Yeah I don't know. It's a good question. I'm, I have a lot of coworkers who are actually super into astrology and tarot, and so, it's kinda fun to play around with it a little bit and just kinda hear what is, what's my, my, my sign tell me about today? But I guess I don't give it any real weight personally. It's just kind of fun. And I guess I don't incorporate it any way in, in tea for me, but I've got nothing against it. Like I, I think it's fun.
I'm born on the solstice, the winter solstice, so I feel like in some ... if you look it up on some places, I'm like Capricorn and in some I'm Sagittarius, I think.
[00:29:23] Jason Cohen: Oh, you're a blend. You're a blend of the two.
[00:29:24] Pat Penny: Yeah, I'm like right, right in that, that date line where I would mix.
[00:29:27] Jason Cohen: Yeah, as long as y- as long as you're not a Scorpio, that's all I know.
[00:29:31] Pat Penny: Yeah, I don't know enough, honestly.
Okay. Thank you for the question, though. All right.
[00:29:39] Jason Cohen: Let's get into, let's get into some serious tea questions.
[00:29:40] Pat Penny: The, the meat and potato tea questions.
[00:29:42] Jason Cohen: Let's go. Let's go.
[00:29:42] Pat Penny: Let's do this. Do you wanna do an email one real quick while I'm brewing this tea?
[00:29:45] Jason Cohen: Do I wanna do an email one? Sure.
Well, actually, here, this was one directed at you, Pat.
[00:29:51] Pat Penny: Uh-oh. Uh-oh.
[00:29:52] Jason Cohen: A- actually it's from me. I, I wrote in my own email question-
[00:29:56] Pat Penny: Okay. ...
[00:29:56] Jason Cohen: Since this is the first time that we got to talk about ... I think this is one of the first times that we get to talk about your writing process. We're always talking about my writing process. And so, some years we're both feeling inspired. Some years I'm inspired. Some years you're inspired. And this year we talked about how difficult you found your side of the trip report to write. And so do you wanna talk a little bit about why and what it's like to be on the writer side of the table with me as an editor versus-
[00:30:24] Pat Penny: Yeah, we definitely can. Yeah.
I don't think I published until the end of June or something like that, right? Or middle of June? I think last year, coming back from Yiwu, I think we probably published within a month of returning. And-
[00:30:39] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[00:30:40] Pat Penny: ... I think, well, for one, I wrote most of that trip report sitting in Wisteria Tea House before even returning to the US. So I was sitting there enjoying a nice, I don't even know at that point. It might've been Taihe or something like that, right? And-
[00:30:53] Jason Cohen: I think you said it was Taihe.
[00:30:54] Pat Penny: And yeah, I was just having a great moment spending some hours there, and I was like, "Well, let me start collecting my thoughts."
And it all felt like it really just came freely and there was things I really wanted to talk about. There was novel experiences that I wanted to share that just felt like they excited me about my tea practice and continuing to learn more. This year in Menghai, it's not that we didn't learn anything. We really did still learn a lot. I guess the things we learned didn't feel as new. It felt like maybe shades or nuances on things we had previously learned being in Yiwu or just previously learned as tea practitioners. Or some of the things we learned were also just not positive or exciting, not the kind of things you wanna share-
[00:31:35] Jason Cohen: Yeah
[00:31:35] Pat Penny: with people always. So, I think as I tried to approach the report, the first thing that was really difficult was just figuring out what do I even write about? 'Cause a lot of what we were doing was, like, it was being on location, right? So do I just talk about, and here's another mountain, and here's another mountain, this is the slight difference in the food we ate with these people versus these people. That didn't really seem like something worth delving deeply on. And it actually helped, you and I went back and forth a couple times and we decided that a constraint on what I would focus on would be most helpful. And so you kind of took sheng puer and general Menghai and maybe also kind of Yunnan history and a lot of things like that. I really just kind of focused on shou puer. And that helped me because Menghai was, a- and doing shou puer was a definitely a newer experience for me.
[00:32:26] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[00:32:26] Pat Penny: And so from there I really felt okay, there's things I want to talk about. There's things that were obviously good or things I would've thought were not so good before being on the trip and seeing how shou puer as a, a commodity tea really works.
So there's just more to share. Even then, as I got to typing, it really kind of felt like things just kind of came out of me matter of fact. Like, there wasn't, there wasn't a lot of passion to tell, I think, this, this year's trip report story.
Jason came back to me with pages of edits, including some prose that was quite, was it Beowulf inspired?
[00:33:01] Jason Cohen: Yeah, yeah.
[00:33:02] Pat Penny: I think you had a little Beowulf inspiration. It felt like there was a little maybe even Jane Austen inspiration in there. So you were very inspired to edit my trip report. I was not particularly inspired to write it, so it did take a long time to come out.
Yours, in fairness, took longer. You did also write maybe seven or eight times the amount that I wrote, so, give and take. So you write maybe on a almost daily basis.
[00:33:28] Jason Cohen: That's right.
[00:33:28] Pat Penny: For me, I, I, I'm not writing on a daily basis. I do a lot of reading. But I definitely think that as I sit down and start to think about what I wanna write, it, it takes me a while to really get to a point where I feel like, "All right, this makes sense. This is the story I wanna tell." And I had done some kind of framing for the trip report multiple times and scrapped a bunch of them before landing on something that you still tore up with a red pen. So, that was my experience of writing this year. I'm still happy with what I put out, but definitely hoping that next year's trip report will come to me like a little bit more of a flash of lightning, some real inspiration.
Did you wanna talk about your writing process this year? Not in the depth we always do, but just like how was writing this trip report versus others?
[00:34:10] Jason Cohen: No I, I thought it was similarly difficult.
[00:34:12] Pat Penny: Yeah.
[00:34:13] Jason Cohen: I... To me, there was lots of things that, that I knew and that I knew that we knew, and there was lots of things that, that felt like covering information that people already have an idea of.
But yeah, I think to your point, so much of what we uncovered this year wasn't exactly immediately or obviously positive, right? It was a lot about finding these diamonds in the roughs and understanding what the process is in Menghai versus a pl- a place like Yiwu. And it was a much harder trip report to write 'cause my, my goal in writing these things is not, this place good, this place bad or, this... I have best tea and these, these other people don't. And y- there's already so much of that type of writing that, that's around and it's not what we do.
So figuring out how do we... A- and putting my own thoughts into order took a really long time to think, what was the reason that we found the situation and what we found there. And, so mine, mine was months later than it normally is coming off, off the trip. Also a little bit longer than some of the past ones, although not crazy much longer, right? I mean, my, my Wuyi two trip reports were pretty long. But I felt like this one required a lot of citation and a lot of framework in order to get to the point where I could say that someone who has read the trip report actually comes away with a better understanding of Menghai than b- before.
[00:35:50] Pat Penny: O- or I would say than is readily available online. I, I feel like other than your trip report, there's really nothing I think that gets across the experience or the context of the realities of tea in Menghai like I think you did in the trip report. So, I think there was a good amount of push from the editorial team to get that information in there, and I'm really happy with the end product and just the way that you wrote. It was quite readable.
Like, when Jason sends us 50-plus page reports or whether it's a chapter for the book, sometimes just opening it is a little difficult. It's like, "Oh man, I know what I'm getting into here." Like I gotta ... Once, once you've sent it, the clock is ticking. This one was actually... it was ... Not to say your others aren't. This was a page-turner. I really found it very easy to read and very easy to edit. Where sometimes, like Yixing, right? A lot of what we're writing is quite heavily fact-based. It's a little bit more textbook-like.
[00:36:42] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[00:36:42] Pat Penny: This was really fun and framed in a way that really unravels like a story, which I really enjoyed. So good- kudos to you. Good job.
We got a live question that I wanted to read. So live question says that, we said previously in a podcast, I think this was the pre-trip podcast, "people say Menghai is strong and aggressive and is the king of tea, and Yiwu is softer and more delicate and is the queen of tea. How would you qualify that now after visiting?" I don't know if I had said it or if you had said it, Jason.
[00:37:10] Jason Cohen: It's a phrase. It's a phrase.
[00:37:11] Pat Penny: Yeah, I know.
[00:37:11] Jason Cohen: It's not something that I subscribe to. I think I wrote in, in, well, I certainly wrote in this trip report that, that this is like the left bank, right bank Bordeaux, and you can highly overgeneralize and say that. But really, all of these areas contain so many sub-regions and Appalachians and sub-sub-sub-regions and gardens and genetic diversity that, that drawing any of these types of over-broad conclusions is very hard.
But it's a little bit easier with Menghai because Menghai produces just so much intensely farmed tea. And when you're tasting a lot of these major blends by either the big factories by Dayi, Xiaguan or others, it contains huge amounts of Menghai leaf material, or tasting some of the, even the boutique blends, particularly the earlier boutique blends circa late 2000, so, like, 2007, '8, '9, right? These contain huge amounts of this, this Bulang second flush or Qiaomu or sometimes even Taidicha materials. And those teas are big and harsh and rough. And some people, particularly in the Western market, have developed a preference for it because that's what they were taught, that puer is this big, bold, flavorful tea.
And there's ways that this tea can be big and bold while still being elegant and beautiful and refined, right? I mean, you have Barolo in wine, which is big and bold while still being elegant and beautiful. You have old vine Grenache in Spain, which is grown in arid desert-like environments, which develops this incredible concentration.
So it's not one or the other, but there's this coarseness, there's this harshness to a lot of this Xiaoshu and Taidi material that's coming out of Bulang that has really made a name for itself as an acquired preference, a preference that I have not acquired or maybe at one point I acquired and have definitely lost. And so, it's not that Yiwu doesn't have that, but Yiwu produces, what is it, Pat, like 1/10th, like 10%?
[00:39:21] Pat Penny: One- one- fifth is what people were telling us when we were there.
[00:39:24] Jason Cohen: One- fifth and far higher percentage of Yiwu is Qiaomu forest tea, gushu tea versus Menghai where it's a tiny, tiny slice.
So, it's, it's not so much that the generalizations are right or wrong. It's that there's shades of truth depending on what you're drinking, right? If you were to... and if you were to compare Taidicha from up mountain Menghai to Taidicha in Yiwu, to an extent the Yiwu would still be slightly lighter flavored, right? Depends what cultivar they wound up where they propped from if it was seed grown. But just generally the terroir in Yiwu produces marginally lighter flavored teas.
[00:40:11] Pat Penny: I will say just to add maybe something a little different to that conversation. Before we went to Menghai, I think that, that was definitely the generalization that I believed as well or that I believe that it might cover 70% of the truth, right? That some part of that is definitely real and then there's parts of that that are totally overgeneralized.
I wasn't sure that I could totally identify differences in Menghai regions. I knew okay, I've had a ton of Bulang tea. I know exactly what that tastes like. I didn't think that I could tell you the difference between, let's say, a Bangpen (帮盆) single region single origin tea and a Bulang blend. I didn't feel super confident that I would know like Banzhang (班章) area versus the rest of Bulang, right?
[00:40:51] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[00:40:52] Pat Penny: After being there, I do feel that a lot of the characteristics in my mind have solidified for a lot of the different regions of Menghai. And, areas like Na Ka or we were talking about Hua Zhu Liang Zi, right? Those are ones that definitely buck the trend of the general taste
[00:41:06] Jason Cohen: Yeah
[00:41:06] Pat Penny: ... profile of the rest of Menghai tea, and obviously they're geographically in slightly different spots. I think Bulang and Menghai in general kind of get conflated as the same thing.
But when we were over in Nannuo (南糯) or over in Pasha, in Na Ka the teas were so distinct from a lot of what we tasted
[00:41:23] Jason Cohen: Very different.
[00:41:23] Pat Penny: Yeah, in Bulang.
[00:41:24] Jason Cohen: Very not Bulang.
[00:41:24] Pat Penny: So I think that was definitely something that helped in my mind to kind of qualify what areas of that phrase are really hyperbole, right? Because those teas do not have that same aggressive character. Although they still do come across a little stronger than Yiwu in the most extremes, right?
[00:41:43] Jason Cohen: Yeah. Yeah.
[00:41:45] Pat Penny: So yeah. Thank you for the question. I think we'll kick it to some of the other questions. This is a good follow-up actually.
So what was the single best cup of Menghai tea that we drank on the trip? Maybe not the most educational or not the best given the circumstances, but just like the best tea that we had on the trip.
[00:42:01] Jason Cohen: Pasha ...
[00:42:02] Pat Penny: Menghai tea. Yeah.
[00:42:03] Jason Cohen: Pasha.
[00:42:04] Pat Penny: Yeah. So when I went through my notes, that was, I, like, I wrote that day, this was like the third day of our trip or the second day, I wrote, "Maybe the best cup of tea in the trip."
And when we finished the trip, we had gone back to Jinghong and we were drinking some Yiwu tea with a friend and I was like, "Damn, this Yiwu tea is the best tea that we had this whole trip."
[00:42:23] Jason Cohen: Well, to clarify, that was more than, that was like a $2 a gram-
[00:42:27] Pat Penny: Yes.
[00:42:28] Jason Cohen:... Like super rarefied, ultra rarefied tea. That would've been good fucking anywhere.
[00:42:32] Pat Penny: It was a tea that we were told was Tianmenshan (天门山) because they basically ha- it's a secret, hyper secret location and, you know, that's vaguely the closest area. And that tea was mind-blowing and definitely the best tea we had the whole trip.
[00:42:44] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[00:42:44] Pat Penny: But second to that...
[00:42:46] Jason Cohen: Pasha.
[00:42:46] Pat Penny: Pasha was great.
[00:42:47] Jason Cohen: Yeah. Yeah.
[00:42:48] Pat Penny: And that's still a tea that I wish we had more of, but the wrapper on that one, that's also a surprising hobby that maybe Jason you could share with people. Your wrapper art design is next level.
[00:42:59] Jason Cohen: Thank you. Thank you. That one has to remain a secret.
That one you have to see in person, but ...
[00:43:04] Pat Penny: I have showed some of my coworkers and they had a good laugh at it.
[00:43:07] Jason Cohen: That's fine. That's fine. That's in person. That's in person.
[00:43:10] Pat Penny: Yeah. Well, the garden is Xiniutang (犀牛塘) and so the wrapper represents that well.
[00:43:15] Jason Cohen: Represents it well. Yeah. I know Pasha and Na Ka were so far out of expectations for- for Menghai for me. Because before this trip, I went through my entire collection and I re-tasted like 16 Menghai teas, some of them going back to like 2007, 2008, 2009. And I came away basically thinking like, wow, my Yiwu teas are now a lot better than my Menghai teas. So going there was an interesting thought process around am I going to find anything that I think is actually quality-wise competitive with this growing access that we have to this amazing Yiwu stuff from all of our time in Yiwu?
And does it exist? Is it there even if we can't buy it, right? What is actually the facts on the ground right now for the teas that are being harvested today? And the, there are parts of Bulang that we love. Lao Ban Zhang has some amazing teas. Lao Man E (老曼峨) has some amazing teas. But the two places that I think that you and I were really taken with were Na Ka and Pasha. And then beyond that-
[00:44:17] Pat Penny: I would throw Nannuo in as a-
[00:44:19] Jason Cohen: That's what I was about to say
[00:44:20] Pat Penny: ... like a third contender.
[00:44:21] Jason Cohen: Well, what I was about to say, Nannuo was like the place that, not written off, but that was like the sleeper that we were like, oh, like we didn't dislike Nannuo, but we also just, I don't know never saw Nannuo and was like, "Oh, I gotta grab the Nannuo tea."
[00:44:36] Pat Penny: If it wasn't on the way from Menghai City, we probably wouldn't have gone.
[00:44:40] Jason Cohen: Yeah. Yeah. And then it turned out to be great. Nannuo was great. But Na- Na Ka and Pasha were really two areas that, that set the bar for Menghai tea in my mind.
[00:44:53] Pat Penny: What you had brought up, like the growing access that we have to some really high quality teas versus like our existing stock, particularly of Menghai teas that we basically acquired most of that in like the late 2000s, early 2010s.
[00:45:07] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[00:45:07] Pat Penny: A lot of that I think to like listeners could sound like a little bit of hyperbole or a little braggadocious, right? Like, we visit Menghai for the first time or you've been before, right? But we visit for a Tea Technique research report and suddenly we are finding teas that are better than anything we've ever gotten, right? Or anything we've bought from Western vendors. How do we I think contextualize that so it doesn't just sound like we're kind of making up like, "Oh, now that we're here, we're getting better things than anyone we could ever source from online."
[00:45:36] Jason Cohen: Yeah. I, so, I mean, again, I think everyone who's here and everyone who ever listens to this knows that we don't sell anything. We don't sell tea. We don't sell teaware, right? We have the books and that's all we do, and we have no financial stake in this stuff. I mean, part of it is that Western market's not going to bear the price that's required in order to get some of these teas, right? Like, a lot of these teas are being bought in plastic bags at a kilo and that's all there is, and it's barely labeled, right? So part of it is just the way that the supply chain works and what the Western market's able to bear.
But part of it is that we put in a huge amount of effort. A, an amount of effort that's actually kind of difficult to communicate, and maybe you can see it a little bit in my trip report, not even an official Tea Technique publication being 80 pages with citations. But we put in a huge amount of effort in getting involved and getting introduced in working through a process of understanding who to trust and who actually has access and who is interested in the educational mission that we're attempting to carry out.
And, a lot of these people are only willing to meet with us because we have no financial interest in this, because we're only going to write about it, because we're not going to attempt to sell any tea and because we keep everything anonymous, right? We keep, we don't attribute phrases or information or knowledge to specific individuals unless it's been previously published, and we do that specifically so people can tell us things that they wouldn't otherwise tell us, like, "These trees have been fertilized. This ground has been tilled," right? "This was an old tree, but this old tree doesn't taste good anymore." And that is a level of trust that people have given us because I've been going to China for 19 years now. I've been publishing the lecture notes and other things for probably 15 years or more, since, at least since 2012, 2013. I think Cult of Quality has been like 2011. And we've been publishing the book since like 2019, right? So I mean, we have a real track record here, and a lot of this stuff is just not commercially viable stuff. There's a reason that we sit with a friend and we drink this tea that we said it was like 2 plus dollars a gram and isn't actually even sold anywhere, and we're like, "This is the most amazing tea that we had this trip." They're like, "I don't know, maybe someone will buy it one day. Maybe we'll have to put it in a blend because it's not cost-effective at that." And there are realities to this being both a business on our contact side. These are people who are tea farmers, who are tea makers who do need to make a living.
And there's a reality to it that the Chinese market is a better market than the Western market for puer, and that if you have something that is in demand, it could be bought a year in advance, sight unseen, before the harvest at prices that the Western market is not going to pay, right? It's not unheard of to see 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, $10 a gram teas.
So, what i- what is it that we're talking about? We cannot always acquire even teas that we would like for our personal collection. Frequently we're shared teas or we're like, "This is amazing." And they're like, "It's mine. I have this bag, 100 grams."
[00:48:56] Pat Penny: I like you a lot, so you can taste some with me.
[00:48:58] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[00:48:58] Pat Penny: But the rest is not for you.
Actually, just bringing back up the best tea that we drank while we were in Menghai. We had a four tree Lao Ban Zhang, select pick, and that's the perfect example of what you're talking about. The friend, right, she shared that tea with us. We actually even got to drink it twice. But when we asked about it, at no point were we ever offered, "You can buy this tea." We said we would buy it, and she's like, "Well, this is all I have."
[00:49:23] Jason Cohen: This is mine.
[00:49:23] Pat Penny: And it's for me.
[00:49:26] Jason Cohen: Yeah. Special family production just for family to drink. A reminder of what great tea tastes like.
[00:49:35] Pat Penny: Yeah. Yeah. And we're like, "Well, if you have anything like this, we would buy it." And, the way that the market works is, as you said, all the teas that are of that caliber are sold out, and that's why she only has that bag.
[00:49:46] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[00:49:46] Pat Penny: Or were never for sale in the first place, right?
[00:49:48] Jason Cohen: Yeah. Never for sale in the first place. I think it's a great question.
I al- I also think it's a great transition to some of the things that farmers or merchants or negociants, people who are in the industry on the China side try to doin order to try to hit that caliber. And so, one of the questions that we got was about the 10 tree single garden danzhu tasting that we did, where we tried some N number of these danzhu trees, all from the same garden, all supposedly quite old, all numbered trees. And they were all harvested singularly as danzhu, and we gave the best tree out of the five whatever we tasted, we gave it a four out of seven. We use a seven-point grading scale. We gave it four points, which is not very high.
[00:50:40] Pat Penny: Yeah. I mean, this was an interesting example of something that's super educational that we could only really experience because of our access to people we knew and being there in that place. But it's one of those, I think, experiences where we had talked about something like this last year when we were in Yiwu with our contacts. They said, "Well, not all single tree teas are actually good." It's not that they're not an old, healthy tree, it's just that from a flavor profile standpoint, not every tree has a potent unique flavor or a specific body feel that you s- seek out or associate with quality. And I think that was the learning experience here was that all these single tree teas that we drank, none of them really stuck out to us as anything special.
[00:51:24] Jason Cohen: No ...
[00:51:24] Pat Penny: And, some of the comments actually that we had online when we were just sharing some of the things that we saw on our trip was n- not verbatim, but you know, oh, well, that probably couldn't be a single tree then. The yield looks too high, or if it doesn't taste good, then it probably wasn't a single tree. And, the people who we're meeting with and discussing have no reason to lie to us. They've purchased these yields in advance. They know the farmers. They work directly with them for a long time and have relationships. This is just the reality of some single tree teas is that not every tea, single tree has the characteristics that you look for in high quality tea.
[00:52:04] Jason Cohen: Yeah. I mean, and this goes both ways. I totally agree with you, but this goes both ways. So on one side, this farmer was producing these trees that would've been better as a blend, right? He had these 10 old trees. These were not bad tasting teas, right? They had good feeling. They felt fine on the palate. But if he had processed them together and then just done a select pick gushu blend, pure gushu, select pick, these 10 trees, blended batch, it would've been superior. But it would've been superior because it would've had more novelty and complexity, and it would've had... there would've been more there for the tea to take.
And on the other side with this type of armchair expert, this what I derisively call the Twitterati, right? Posting comments like, "Oh, well that's too high yield for a danzhu," or that " the great danzhus are great". Look, a lot of what's labeled as danzhu on the market isn't danzhu. We keep hearing people say, "Well, danzhu." And we're like, "Danzhu?" And they're like, "Three tree danzhu blend. Four tree danzhu blend. Five tree danzhu blend." It's like, like, "Hey, motherfucker, I don't know if you know the language you're speaking, but danzhu means single tree."
[00:53:14] Pat Penny: And it's interesting you say that, right? Because I had even just mentioned one of the best teas we had, right, was a four-tree blend.
[00:53:19] Jason Cohen: Four tree, yeah.
[00:53:20] Pat Penny: But the person we were tasting with said, "Well, it's danzhu." And,
[00:53:24] Jason Cohen: Four tree danzhu
[00:53:25] Pat Penny: ... it's a four-tree danzhu, and this is a-
[00:53:27] Jason Cohen: A four tree danzhu
[00:53:27] Pat Penny: ... this is a Chinese person speaking in Mandarin. It's a four-tree danzhu. So I think it's a, a matter of usage across the board.
[00:53:34] Jason Cohen: Yeah ...
[00:53:34] Pat Penny: It's kind of the same thing we see with gushu, and I think that we've talked ad nauseam, right? Sometimes it is actually over X number of years. Sometimes it's just a big tree. Is it dashu? Is it gushu? Doesn't matter. It might all be good tea, it might not be. You have to actually really taste the tea that's presented in front of you without all of the labels and decide from there if it's ... Is it good? Do you like it? Is it worth X price, right?
[00:53:58] Jason Cohen: Yeah. But to ... I think that question helps round out this idea of what's actually available and what's cost-effective because that farmer is doing that. He's separating out those single trees so that a buyer will pay more or so that a negociant will say, "I'm gonna take... I tasted these 10 and I'm gonna take trees three, nine, and eight, and I'm gonna blend them." And then it's the negociant's problem. And really honestly, this, that tea, that garden would've been better served by just being a select pick gushu blend. And so yeah, I don't ... maybe the farmer will sell out of the tea or maybe he won't, but he's been doing this on and off we heard for five, six years. And I d- I don't think it's a good development. I think that's chasing a hype cycle that his specific trees can't bear.
[00:54:54] Pat Penny: A- as we tasted, but, but our friend bought them, so-
[00:54:58] Jason Cohen: To blend ...
[00:54:59] Pat Penny: I don't know.
[00:54:59] Jason Cohen: Our friend bought them to blend.
[00:55:00] Pat Penny: Yes, yes.
[00:55:00] Jason Cohen: And she had some prearranged buyers who want, who don't know anything about tea and want some danzhu, but that's a, that's a different story.
[00:55:07] Pat Penny: A- another thing that the market is bearing. You've got, you've got people with enough money who just want something called danzhu. Doesn't matter how many trees are in that danzhu.
[00:55:16] Jason Cohen: Yeah, although in that case, I think that there was, she was going to confirm a single tree.
[00:55:21] Pat Penny: Unrelated, I did wanna talk about, so you just broached the Twitterati, the armchair experts as you were writing about Sheng Puer, the development of Sheng Puer, kind of the history of tea processing at ethnic minority sites and as it's kind of being introduced to Han Chinese influence and how puer kind of as a region and as a style developed. There's a lot of ideas online about green tea puer, pu-long and a lot of things online just don't get it right. Is there anything more you wanna say about it other than the very blunt phrasing you had in the trip report? If someone never reads the trip report but they're listening to this, what would you want them to know about those info hazards?
[00:56:01] Jason Cohen: I want them to know that the info hazard is real, that the conception that people are likely to develop by following the current public English language discourse on puer and in faults in puer is factually wrong. And it is provably factually wrong. This idea of green tea puer and xin gongyi (新工艺) and pu-long maybe at the low end of the market, maybe in lowland plantation teas, maybe in some one, one-off lower end productions might really be a thing. But at the higher end, at the boutique level, at any- anything that anyone's really paying for and recommending, that's not what's going on. It's not what's happening. There was a whole group of people who are online saying all this Yiwu tea is green tea puer which is pardon my French, Deer dick. And-
[00:57:05] Pat Penny: That wasn't French.
[00:57:07] Jason Cohen: Yeah. Muntjac. Muntjac dick. Yeah, whi- which is bullshit. That's not what's happening. There's no one who, at the highest end, who has access to gushu teas that's doing some... maybe there's one farmer out there somewhere or one processor that's doing this, but there is no mass movement towards this idea of pulong or green tea puers. There's no xin gongyi that's infected the market in Yiwu. It's just not a thing. It's not, it's not what's happening. It's not what's going on.
One of the ways that we know this, because that's obviously a series of very strong statements. But, Pat and I, we show, as Max Falkowitz from Leafhopper likes to say, we show our work. One of the ways that we know this is that we actually commissioned a series of sets. Last year we commissioned a rounian (揉捻) set where we did different levels of rolling process in order to see the levels of bruising and their effects on the tea. And then this year we did a set of shaqing sets which I wrote about in the trip report very briefly, where we did three thing, three shaqings, the middle being the normal, and then we did a high-fire short time and a long lower heat longer time based on a technique that we actually saw in Lao Ban Zhang. And the attribution that everyone has on the internet is wrong. It's totally wrong. The attribution, this idea that people are producing this green tea puer and then they're pointing at these puers, we know that those puers are actually medium to longer shaqings, that those puers are actually less green than some of the puers that they're pointing at, particularly some of the factory puers, the factory sourcing puers which are more green in order for them to change faster. And neither of them are actually processed like green tea. In some areas like Lincang, there is this high heat, fast processing style that exists, and that does produce something that tastes more like green tea with a very different leaf composition. But that's not what, in general, this Western conversation has been about. It's total misidentification of the attribution of cup quality to processing. And in fact, in doing so much of this work and doing so much of this sourcing, in doing so much of this on-site tasting where we really have a very clear idea of what's in the cup, we know that a lot of these attributes and a lot of the things that people are either identifying as good or as bad are actually from whether or not it's gushu tea, whether or not it's first flush or second flush, whether or not it's, it's, a good healthy tree or whether it's totally fertilized and weak and stressed trees. And so- it's, it's not an easy thing to write about. I certainly have a reputation, I think, for being opinionated and potentially abrasive.
[00:59:51] Pat Penny: You stir the pot.
[00:59:52] Jason Cohen: Yeah. Yeah, I s- I stir the pot.
[00:59:53] Pat Penny: You flip the wok.
[00:59:55] Jason Cohen: Yeah. Yeah, I light some fires and... but any- anyone who drinks tea with me regularly knows, right, these aren't off the cuff opinions, that I put in the effort to do the work and I'm always receptive to new information. And then I've publicly said multiple times on our podcast or in the editorial conversations and the trip reports where my opinion has changed, where we've proven ourselves wrong. And it's not, it's not super fun to, to always have to say, "Well, actually the entire Western conception of this, the entire conversation about this, this idea that everyone's promoting is wrong."
And there's not a conversation that I feel like I can be a part of without right now playing a bad cop lecturer professor and saying "Can we just talk about something that's real? Can like, can we get off of this i- idea that people are promoting who don't even go to Yunnan, who don't even process tea?" Right? Who it... Why are we listening to them tell us about flaws in cups for teas that they don't like, they don't, they've never been there and they don't understand? And then when you ask them for recommendations they're like, "Drink Dayi." Okay, you drink fucking Dayi.
[01:01:11] Pat Penny: Well, actually. So I think it's important to clarify, right? The argument that you're making is not that Dayi good or anything like that and that-
[01:01:21] Jason Cohen: No ...
[01:01:21] Pat Penny: It's not that processing is unimportant. In fact, processing's extremely important. It's just that we've, we've gotten our facts wrong in the Western market with where we attribute certain flavor profiles to certain, quote-unquote, "flaws" in processing.
I think something that w- was really well addressed through the trip report as well was this idea of xin gongyi, which we touched a lit- a little bit in your previous answer. But I think in the trip report really helps to just take a step back and see xin gongyi is not a change in processing from, let's call it, the mid-2000s where people just go from the family dinner wok to they've constructed actual tea processing areas and-
[01:02:00] Jason Cohen: Yeah ...
[01:02:00] Pat Penny: now they have better technology to make the tea, right? Xin gongyi is this entire idea of the past couple hundred years of the influence of Han in regional teamaking and the, the changes and influence of technology and different people's taste on tea processing of those once indigenous people. What are people getting wrong about xin gongyi specifically?
[01:02:23] Jason Cohen: Well, I think you said it great. The way that it's used now, particularly in Xishuangbanna is very derisive. It's saying, "Oh, tho- those people do xin gongyi. that tea is no good. That tea won't age," right? "That tea doesn't take on the right characteristics."
[01:02:34] Pat Penny: That's, that's green tea puer, something to that extent, right?
[01:02:37] Jason Cohen: Yeah, green tea puer, right? Versus this longer, bigger idea of xin gongyi. Because, if you look at the difference between Menghai and Yiwu, a lot of the difference is driven by Han in migration into Yiwu, where Shi Ping (石屏) Han a educated merchant class moved into the mountains bringing their books and letters with them and attempting to recreate a literati society, a merchant literati society, but a literati society. This is in Qing dynasty when the rising merchant class was already trying, attempting to turn in themselves into literati. And so this is multi-generations deep particularly from in migration from Shi Ping, which was known as a City of Letters. And they brought this idea with them. And so they displaced a lot of the minority groups or a lot of the local growers, and they took on the ideas of tea farming that had been practiced elsewhere. They took on seed stock and other ideas that had been practiced elsewhere and it hybridized it and migrated and it, and it became something very unique to Yiwu.
And that is in stark contrast to what happened in Menghai, where you had feudal Dai lords making deals with up mountain minorities for supplying tea that was going to be transshipped to other Southeast Asian or other minority groups in, in Tibet and elsewhere. And so the levels of skill and practice varied drastically. The level of technique and craft varied drastically. And so up until you had Han merchants attempting to go into the mountains and purchase tea circa turn of century, Republic of China era into like 1918 and 1930, they trusted the Dai middlemen to process their tea. They didn't want the up mountain minority groups to actually, particularly in Menghai, to process the tea. They didn't think that the tea that they processed was any good. And so it was actually farmers to Dai middlemen to Han merchants to transshipment out of China was the line of production, the line of, of flow in Menghai. This was never a domestic product. This was never a product that was intended for Han preferences. And I think I lost the, the official thread of the question, but
[01:04:58] Pat Penny: Well, no, I think you're, you're on the right track for what I think we were hoping for here. But a- as you had just talked about that Qing dynasty history, and we move into modern, let's quote unquote modern, let's call it the last 100 years of tea processing. We, we see people attribute nowadays in the, the modern conversation the cakes of the masterpiece era as that is traditional processing, and what's being done in boutique teas now is xin gongyi, right?
[01:05:22] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[01:05:22] Pat Penny: But, but in fact, it's, it's either all xin gongyi or it's all traditional processing because what, what we're calling puer today and what we would've called puer 100 years ago might not really be the same thing.
[01:05:34] Jason Cohen: Yeah, not, not, not, the same thing. So, the, the techniques that were being used in order to bring tea to Han people in Guangzhou and to a limited extent Beijing and very few other places coming out of Yiwu would've been very lightly processed, would've been closer to a green tea. Some of the merchants' tea going around there still would've been on the, the lighter flavored side versus the Menghai productions where, we talk about shou puer as something that was developed in 1950s, 1960s, right? In 1972 as a commercial run that was based on earlier work that was done in Guangzhou or in the production of pile fermented Liu Bao.
But actually if you look at the tea that was sent to Tibet, much of that was wettened, moistened and allowed to go with golden flowers, Eurotium and then compressed. And so you actually had pre-moistening going back into late Qing through the ROC era for shipment into, into Tibet. So, okay, so is, is it that traditional? We're, we're not calling everything that we're doing now at Menghai xin gongyi when before it had golden flowers in it. And if someone made a golden flower puer today, everyone would be screaming about, "Well, this is experimental. This isn't traditional." You, you actually wanted to fact check that twice. You, you requested quite a bit of evidence . You're like, "I have not heard this before."
[01:06:58] Pat Penny: I just gotta make sure that there's no extrapolation happening. I need to make sure that everything is grounded in a source.
[01:07:05] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[01:07:05] Pat Penny: I think what I maybe was also hoping to arrive at from this thread of questioning was that I think for at least the Western market and the Western tea consumer there's this idea that teas of let's call it the, the 1950s through the early 2000s are traditional. And, anything from that point on, you have a mix of traditional processing and modern processing. And as we sat and talked with farmers and obviously looked at other sources and looked at historical sources, you still see today even just in Menghai, right, in a relatively small region, a range of processes for high quality teas that are all considered a, a standard or well processed tea. There is no one single process for puer, and there is no one true historic process for puer. It continues to be a, a living, style of tea, a living class of tea that processing continues to evolve, technology continues to evolve, and people's preferences continue to evolve. If you want it to go in the direction that you prefer then, like learn, learn how to taste good tea and talk, talk positively about that. I think, continuing to try and look for faults when you don't have a full understanding of the developmental history is not positive for the the continued growth of puer.
[01:08:21] Jason Cohen: No. The two things that I wanna add to this, one is that when we talk about this, the Western conception, when we talk about what's going on in the Western market, I actually do not find that the Western facing vendors who sell predominantly to, to the United States and Europe but who live in China, who are actually present on the fields, who are present during manufacture, they don't tend to be making these arguments. They don't tend to be making these misattributions and mistakes. This is very much a, a lay tea purchaser, tea drinker, tea aficionado, tea blogger mistake. So, so that, that's, that's one. So, if, if you're talking about people who are actually on site making tea, it's not the kind of thing that really comes up.
And the second thing is this idea of, of what's right and what's wrong. I write about this, I try to write about this in the trip reports, this idea of, of metis, right? Of personal embodied skill. How long should a wine be on oak? How long should these grapes stay on skins? Should you strain? Should you whole cluster? Should you carbonic macerate? Whiskey, right? Should these be blended? Has it been in the cask long enough? Are we going to do, release this as a single batch? In tea, are we going to wither? How long are we going to wither? Are we going to shaqing at what heat and what heat can we handle right now? And how much wok do we have to move? And how long are we gonna rou nian? Which rou nian machines are available? Or how much hand labor is available in order to rou nian this?
There's so much metis that these ideas of simplified rules that puer needs to be picked and then it's not withered, it's put directly into the wok, and it's a high heat wok, and it's gonna be in the wok for some amount of time, and then it's gonna be rolled, and it's gonna be sun-dried, right? There are... I skipped what I would consider now, now what I would consider to be half the steps in this normal conception. And more than half these steps have options. All of these steps have options. This idea that puer isn't withered, again, this is th- this, this is over-categorization. This is not the reality, right? The tea is sometimes accidentally withered or incidentally withered after it's picked because it comes from deep in the forest. The tea is sometimes purposely withered because they look at the leaf and they say, "This leaf is really turgid, and it's, it's not gonna taste right if we do it."
And it's-
[01:10:52] Pat Penny: Sometimes it's purposely withered for 13 plus hours because it's cold on Nannuo that day, and the, you know processor is looking for a certain orchid aroma before he starts to fire his tea. And so we sit there for a long time.
[01:11:06] Jason Cohen: Yeah. So, this, this idea of, these strict rules doesn't match the reality. There is a personal embodied skill that tea makers, good tea makers develop, and it's not replaceable by this, the, this, this conceptual knowledge, this book reading knowledge, I could attempt to write the books without going there, without being there and it would be book knowledge. It wouldn't have the, the verisimilitude. It wouldn't match the realities on the ground, right?
My, my goal in writing is to get across this level of nuance that goes beyond base categorizations around right and wrong and good and bad, and, and, gets into the real trade-offs, the real decisions that people have to make. And, and I think so much of the commentary right now online is inconducive to it and doesn't help people learn and doesn't help you develop a, a palette and an insight and a working knowledge about how to attribute different d- different aspects of what you're perceiving and tasting and purchasing back to the, the actual process.
[01:12:30] Pat Penny: So we've got a question submitted live in the chat. I think just following up on your answer, Jason.
[01:12:35] Jason Cohen: Okay.
[01:12:36] Pat Penny: Where does that desire to over-index come from in the Western market? So maybe, maybe over-indexing in very specific understanding, right? Of like processing or maybe that's having some exactitude. Where do you think that comes from?
[01:12:49] Jason Cohen: Well, we write about this a lot in book one about this idea of classification about arts or conceptions or an aesthetic of distinction versus an aesthetic of reference. And tea, tea often falls into both, but China itself is an aesthetic of distinction. It's very much these things are separate because they come from separate areas, because they have separate materials, they have separate processes. So that is preexisting in tea world. And I don't, I don't consider that to be an exclusively Western thing. I think that a lot of tea is a geeky hobby and a lot of geeky people who like details, same as wine or same as whiskey or whatever, right? Where there's details where you could start to say, "This is cool because now I can tell the difference between these things."
And I think where it goes off the rails in the Western world is the commentariat, right? The, the Twitterati, the peanut gallery, the armchair experts. I, I think that it's, it's easy to say, "Well, this person is more knowledgeable," or, " This person's been drinking tea longer than me," or, "This person has spent more on tea or has a larger collection than me."
And therefore, When they say, "This is green tea puer," I'm going to believe them, I'm gonna attribute that. So in short what I'm railing against is, is info hazard versus distinction. It's very fun to be able to make distinction. We win a lot of points being able to blind identify stuff. I was just at a tea tasting with a bunch of people who own tea import companies who are big sourcers. I'm not a sourcer. I, I don't, I don't have to make any decisions. And so they kept wanting to share teas and show off what they had, and everyone was very friendly. Everyone brought fun stuff. And I just kept saying, "Blind, blind, blind," and identifying it. Won tons of brownie points. But there's, there's certainly an allure to it, right? You can... You, you get to show off some, some knowledge and some skill. I don't know, maybe not everyone there was willing to subject themselves to that. That's why they made me... I, I said blind, and then they said, "Okay, you do blind."
[01:14:54] Pat Penny: And then suddenly it's, "No, thank you."
[01:14:57] Jason Cohen: Well, I did it. I did, I did great.
[01:15:03] Pat Penny: Yeah. Thank you for the question. I think maybe following on this, this isn't a question that was submitted. Maybe, maybe the rest of the AMA will just shit on the commentators, right? Well, the Twitterati. No, we won't do that. But what, what does kind of grind my gears specifically in that camp is we- we've got a lot of bloggers we love. A lot of them are fellow tea people we really like. There is like this subclass nowadays of bloggers who are also tea vendors. And that's, that's something that I personally can't stand. So it's this group of people who and I'm not talking about one specific person, I'm just saying this, this category of bloggers-
[01:15:38] Jason Cohen: There's a group ...
[01:15:39] Pat Penny: who, blog, blog about tea for like a year and then suddenly they turn around and they're selling some sort of tea related thing, whether it's curated tasting experiences. And, they use their blog kind of as a means to say like, "Well, I know better because I've been, I've tasted these things and that things."
[01:15:56] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[01:15:57] Pat Penny: I think maybe what really maybe bothers me more is like misattribution on other people's teas and then pointing to their own and saying, "Well, mine is better for X, Y, Z reasons." And I know maybe this is something that you've seen as well as you've been reading through the blogs, which I don't, I don't think you do as much as I do. I share things with you. But you know, where, where do you think that, that kind of, the rise of that style of commentator will lead us as like just a, a Western tea collective? What do you think it'll do to the general culture of tea practitioners in the West?
[01:16:28] Jason Cohen: Oh, oh, it's, it's bad, right? I mean, we talk about merchant myths all the time. There's already merchant myths that have become so prevalent, it's just what people repeat in base explanations, right? I, I think that this rise of, of underguised bloggers, bloggers who are doing it in order to promote... so much of the information right now in the Western conception was given to us by merchants, and not all of it is bad. People need to be educated. Beginner education is real and difficult and hard, and I've said publicly many times, it's not my role in the community. And, and, and not what I focus on. But someone has to do it. Who would be reading this book, right, if not for beginner education? There needs to be some access and some idea and some common ground in order for people, in order to acquire the preferences, in order to move through the market and get to the point where they're saying, "I will definitely spend $10 a gram on this Yibang gushu danzhu and share it with Jason."
Right? Some- some- something's gotta give. But on the other hand, you have to trust the merchant, and we've written about this extensively, that if, that, mm, merchants have different levels of knowledge and different levels of trust and different levels of believing in their own hype and not believing in their own hype.
So there's many a times where merchants publish something and say "This is this, and it's great for these reasons, and we recommend it because of X, Y, and Z, and it's very limited." And sometimes it's knowably wrong, and there's an intent to deceive. Sometimes that's what they were told, and they believe it.
So I think the real problem here is now that it's gotten snippy, is that different merchants are now like calling themselves out, "those guys, that's no good. That won't age. That xin gongyi green tea pu-long, its both too green and over-rolled and oxidized. And if you want the good stuff, you should buy my stuff. Cuz my stuff is made by my tea master. And this is just, this is unhelpful.
[01:18:37] Pat Penny: Not the direction we wanna go. Well, how do we, maybe not you and I specifically, how does this get remedied? We're, we're not gonna solve it, but what, what would need to happen?
[01:18:46] Jason Cohen: I don't know. I'll write a book on puer and people will read it and they'll ask their merchant hard questions.
[01:18:53] Pat Penny: We hope.
[01:18:54] Jason Cohen: I guess.
[01:18:54] Pat Penny: That's, that's the hope at the end of the day.
[01:18:55] Jason Cohen: I did see, one, one, one person at this gathering, I thought this was very cool, very rare do I compliment merchants. This merchant at this gathering put the house number on his labels, on his cakes. They're his labels, his branded, his tea, but he puts the house number. Made at, made with family at house number 33, house number 55, whatever per village. I thought that was very, very cool because now anyone who actually knows something about tea knows, "I know what that family's doing. I know what that house is doing." And I thought that that was very odd and cool decision.
[01:19:31] Pat Penny: That, that's awesome. That does bring me to another observation of mine recently that I shared with you. We also have vendors who might be selling one tea but attribute it to another tea maker, right? So maybe a related tea maker. There, there's a certain point where I think the fame by association or the very specific distinction of this was made by this tea maker might become, start to become harmful, particularly when it's incorrect, right? How, do we address that as a tea community? Is that even something we, we bother to address?
[01:20:05] Jason Cohen: We bring it to the makers and let them work it out. I, Y- there's so many levels there, so in China, because of the way the hukou system works and because of the way that village residency and, and having access to gushu gardens and, and picking rights for national forest tea that's in national forest land and, and famous trees, you have a family and then suddenly this family has children, and then those children grow up, and then you fenjia, right? The household splits. They get married and now they wanna move out.
Okay. So which son or which daughter inherits which access rights and who continues to have access rights and who continues to live at the family home and who moves out but is gifted access or gifted a plot. And, and these things are, I mean, this is family politics. Doesn't get any more complicated than this, right? This, this, makes the Russian system look easy. So, sometimes it's very, very friendly, and the family stays together, and they're, oh so harmonious, and they process together, and they keep the family reputation. And other times, you have N number of warring brothers and sisters, some of who have good access and some of whom don't. And then everything is sold under the father's name because the father was the famous one who got the reputation. And it's like, okay, well, why does this tea from this one family vary so wildly in quality? You have different sons and daughters making different levels of tea.
[01:21:35] Pat Penny: Yeah. And I, it goes back once again, some- sometimes maybe the merchants don't even actually understand the distinction.
[01:21:40] Jason Cohen: Yeah. No.
[01:21:41] Pat Penny: So it might not be deceitful, it might not be maligned in any way. It's just they sell it because they bought it from who they think they bought it from.
[01:21:49] Jason Cohen: We got in some write-in questions. So Tea Technique has been commissioning specific tea experiments. If we could do one for shou, what would it be?
[01:21:59] Pat Penny: That's tough, because I feel like um, it's not really a, a cost issue I think for you and I. I think it's a space issue. And particularly, you're moving, right? It's a space issue. If we were to commission shou puer, we would need to go in with maybe a vendor, because I I don't wanna commission a, a multi-ton batch or multiple multi-ton batches of shou puer. Sheerly on a space constraint level.
[01:22:23] Jason Cohen: Yeah. Well, maybe, maybe unpack that a little bit, because you, you wrote about this in your trip report. But the scale of shou puer, and I, I, and I think we could write a little bit about our thoughts on... We can speak a little bit about our thoughts on boutique shou puer. So, so there's this idea right now, boutique shou puer. Go.
[01:22:41] Pat Penny: Yeah. So, boutique shou puer, these small batch fermentations, which can be anything from a ton down, still not necessarily that small. But these are fermentation techniques that might be using pitched yeast or a controlled environment of some sort, whether it comes to temperature or humidity or off-the-floor beds, crated fermentation. There's a lot of these different modern techniques to achieve a very specific end outcome. And generally, this is kind of what's viewed as boutique puer, and often the raw materials used for it are generally thought to be higher quality raw materials. So you might have more of a older tree input, and you expect with a cleaner process, you might have a better output.
I think when we were in Menghai, we got to see a lot of different perspectives on boutique versus let's call it standard scale, maybe not commodity shou puer. And, and we found that there was a lot of teas that we liked that went through a standard floor processing using let's call it like good, but not maybe- exemplary raw material that outperformed a lot of teas that would've been made of like quote unquote "exemplary raw material," so talking about gushu or even danzhu with a more modernized process off the floor or specific pitch yeast strains. And we found a lot of these traditional style teas outperformed a lot of those boutique teas. . It's funny to talk about that now after the conversation on xin gongyi, right? 'Cause now it kind of feels like we're traditionalists when it comes to shou puer. But I think, I, I think it's not to say that it's traditional, right? We're talking about a, a processing method that's only, you know, 60-odd years old. It's not like it's old old.
[01:24:18] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[01:24:19] Pat Penny: But, we, we found at least with the tea makers we were working with that older style created a more unique novel flavor profile. M- and when we, I think, kind of follow it from a first principle standpoint, you've got a wider range of substrate being fermented with a potentially wider range of fermenting agents. And so you're yielding just potentially more flavorsome or unique outputs.
From there it becomes a matter of cost as well. With these larger scale fermentations, you end up with like on a per gram basis, often a, a cheaper end product. And so of course in a market flooded with really bad raw material being processed with in, in some areas potentially questionable processing, you end up with this range of teas that are really, really cheap, and it's kinda hard to know like what's good and what's bad because just because it's not expensive doesn't actually mean that it's bad shou puer. So kind of back to the commission and, and then maybe you can add on your two cents there.
[01:25:16] Jason Cohen: Well, well before you, you s- because, because it plays into this, this idea of what would we commission. So, we got to try all of this very interesting contemporary shou puer. There's some small batch stuff that's now here in the Western market, some that, that varies in quality. Generally, I have found that the, the, the floor fermentation large batch process tastes better to me, tastes fuller to me, tastes more like shou puer to me. And part of the reason is because, and Pat, we experience this, right? Trying to dig your hand d- deep into the pile is that there are different colonies that affect the shou puer, that ferment the shou puer at different rates at different times over the course of its fermentation. And if the pile doesn't get big enough, you don't get that range. 'Cause that range is both temporal over time, but also based on the pile. The top of the pile
[01:26:10] Pat Penny: Yeah. So heat
[01:26:11] Jason Cohen: ... which is drier.
[01:26:12] Pat Penny: Yeah, heat, humidity, and oxygen exposure, right?
[01:26:15] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[01:26:15] Pat Penny: And these are things that can't be replicated in smaller fermentations.
[01:26:19] Jason Cohen: Yeah. Exactly. So they can't be... And so this idea of cleanliness driving quality is not what we found. What, what we actually found is that the larger batches produce a more unique and a more complete flavor profile than a lot of these small batch productions. And, and so given that, we did not develop a preference for a lot of these unique small batches.
And then we got the chance to work with a company that's doing some really novel and interesting things. Things that from a science, from a learning, from an educational perspective I love. And from a preference perspective I think that these are fine, interesting teas. But they're doing a lot of single strain inoculation. Right? They're, they're doing just Aspergillus niger. They're doing just Lactobacilli. They're doing just
[01:27:06] Pat Penny: Like specific yeast strain pitches.
[01:27:09] Jason Cohen: Yeah. Sac- the-
[01:27:10] Pat Penny: Yeah, Saccharomyces
[01:27:11] Jason Cohen: ... Saccharomyces
[01:27:11] Pat Penny: Of, of, multiple varieties, but yeah, like cerevisiae, right? Like brewer's yeast.
[01:27:15] Jason Cohen: And they all tasted very monotonal, even when they were using incredibly expensive materials. I lo- I like the commentary.
[01:27:26] Pat Penny: Yeah. Live comment. You heard it here first. Small batch shou is overrated. And it's not to say that, I'm sure there's small batch shous out there that would knock our socks off. Whether we think they're worth the price points, I don't know. But I think our idea, our conception of what is good shou puer fits more in line with a lot of these larger, more traditional style batches.
[01:27:48] Jason Cohen: Yeah. Still good batches, but yeah.
[01:27:50] Pat Penny: Yes.
[01:27:50] Jason Cohen: I mean, we, we got some shou given to us by the kilo in a garbage bag as a gift for visiting. We tasted it once and we said, "This belongs in the garbage bag."
[01:28:00] Pat Penny: And that was traditional floor fermentation once again. So raw materials, process, all those things still matter. But given, I think, equivalent inputs, I would prefer the traditional process output.
[01:28:14] Jason Cohen: Agreed. So you were saying, so you would commission?
[01:28:17] Pat Penny: Ah, so yeah, if we were, if given unlimited budget, I do think I would be interested to kind of delve deeper into some of the effects of, like, the fermentation percentage from like the farmer or the processor's perspective. So a lot of them were talking about this kind of like, let's call it 70 to 80% done or fermented range. I think getting an idea of like same material, same area or same fermentation location, same maker but just like ending slightly different times, right? So they believe this is a 75, this is a 78, this is an 83 or something like that, right? Really getting nitty-gritty on the fermentation rate according to the processor. That would be something that would be, I feel like, very educational. Once again, like many things that we process, not all of those I think are gonna be good. If we had like an 80 plus percent fermented batch, I have a feeling that would be the one that we end up, you know
[01:29:13] Jason Cohen: A little muddy.
[01:29:14] Pat Penny: Yeah.
[01:29:14] Jason Cohen: Cool.
[01:29:15] Pat Penny: But, but still highly educational. Highly educational. I think-
[01:29:18] Jason Cohen: I was gonna go the other way with that, 'cause you, you, you were thinking in an educational set. I was like, what do I, what would I actually enjoy? And I was thinking like a higher end, like a, a mixed gushu and gushu huang pian Ban Zhang five village cha tou.
[01:29:39] Pat Penny: Would you have that gushu and that gushu huang pian processed as separate batches and then blended? Because we learned the huang pian is gonna finish much earlier.
[01:29:48] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[01:29:48] Pat Penny: Just based on the substrates available and the moisture content.
[01:29:51] Jason Cohen: Oh, yeah.
[01:29:51] Pat Penny: If you did it together, you might get a really huang pian that's overdone and the other material that's underdone. Right?
[01:29:57] Jason Cohen: Probably, probably separate, maybe blend. But I'm, what I'm really interested in is the cha tou. Like, let's do a high-end cha tou.
[01:30:03] Pat Penny: Yeah. I'm, I'm here for it. How do we get the just the dankest, thickest clumps in the middle of the fermentation pile? I, I think the challenge when we talk about commissions for puer, we talked about the price point. I think just for the listeners putting it to scale, when we commission, a, a batch of raw puer, right? We're often buying by the, the woks worth. So, approximately seven-ish kilograms of raw material is gonna yield close to one kilogram of finished puer, and that's an easy thing for farmers to say, "Yeah, sure. We'll throw a wok for you. No problem."
I- there, there's no equivalent for shou. We can't just be like, "Oh, yeah. We'll just buy that 100 kilograms. Please process that as a small batch." E- even though the price point of the raw material is probably gonna be a bit lower than what we'd normally want for a sheng commission, there's just no way that we are hitting the scale necessary to commission a shou batch by ourselves.
[01:30:58] Jason Cohen: No. There's, there's no way. We, we will likely be never be able to commission shou. We get 1,000 readers and we could send the readers the shou. We can do a shou batch. We can do our, my Ban Zhang five village cha tou.
[01:31:12] Pat Penny: Yeah. Not, not a question, but I was really pleasantly surprised maybe that I, I had come in believing that like, of course we've had a lot of Menghai shou. Menghai is generally where a lot of shou's coming from. We had the opportunity to have a couple Yiwu shous and I think my Yiwu supremacy, I thought I was gonna be like, "Well, now that we're drinking Yiwu shous, I'm, I'm gonna like that more." And I think I really was like pleasantly surprised by how much, whether it's my preference was formed by Ban Zhang shou puers or whether it's truly that they produce more interesting and more unique teas. I was happy to come out of that trip being like, "Well, Ban Zhang is, is my location for puer, shou puer." And you know I don't have to seek out very specific Yiwu, yeah, villages or anything like that. Like, the Ban Zhang shou will do it for me.
[01:32:03] Jason Cohen: It's not much, it's not much of a thing, the Yiwu shous. I, I picked up a Yiwu gong ting super buddy, very lightly shou puer shou. Just it was weird and I enjoyed it and it wasn't very expensive and I grabbed it and Pat didn't grab it. Pat, we were like, "You're buying that?" Like...
[01:32:22] Pat Penny: It was a good tea. It was just at, I, I think at that point my, once again, storage situation.
[01:32:27] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[01:32:28] Pat Penny: I was just like, "I don't know where I'm putting 200 grams of gong ting shou puer."
[01:32:31] Jason Cohen: I just, I liked it. I don't know, it's a random thing to pull out and drink.
[01:32:35] Pat Penny: Yeah.
[01:32:35] Jason Cohen: So.
[01:32:35] Pat Penny: I feel like may- maybe we're at closers. Do we wanna do some like hot takes or anything like that?
[01:32:40] Jason Cohen: We could do a hot take. Do we have one more serious question?
Let's see. Well, no, I feel like we don't wanna beat a dead horse, but we got the question about people on Instagram questioning, "Well, that's not what I see. That's not what I do. I was a merchant." So the question is, I guess, how do we know that we're right?
[01:33:01] Pat Penny: Yeah. That's a good question for you. How do you know you're right, Jason? How do you know you're right? You know- I don't- Why, why are you right, and this other person who also dedicates their life to tea is wrong?
[01:33:11] Jason Cohen: Have they really dedicated their life to tea, Pat?
[01:33:14] Pat Penny: I don't know.
[01:33:15] Jason Cohen: I don't think they've taken the blood oath.
[01:33:17] Pat Penny: That's true.
I don't think they've done it. They might not be in the secret, they might not be in the secret society.
[01:33:21] Jason Cohen: No, no. Taoist Sigma Alpha is an exclusive club. How do I know you're right? So we, I think we... I feel like we got called out in two things. Someone was like, "Oh, well my shou puer is not that fermented." And I don't know what to say, guy. We were there. We saw it. We tasted these shous. We've tasted a lot of shous. The good shous were that fermented, like super-duper fermented. If you're trying to push your small batch shou, raised off the floor, like obviously less fermented, we tasted that, and we're with our, our writing, our trip report is that we like the floor ferment more, despite our assumptions, despite what we went in thinking.
[01:34:00] Pat Penny: Yeah. I think maybe we caveat with we don't have anything specific against any- any said vendor. I think maybe what annoys me, and I don't know if you feel the same way, the most about these sorts of engagements is that it does feel like oh, you saw this and I think you're wrong because of X, but I sell my product, right? And so it does feel a little bit like engagement on social media for the purpose of marketing their own product.
[01:34:24] Jason Cohen: Yeah, it didn't-
[01:34:24] Pat Penny: And I don't know if this person's intention is that, but if that's how-
[01:34:27] Jason Cohen: It didn't feel like a constructive engagement, right? It was very much like it doesn't have to be that fermented. My stuff is much cleaner. Which also is at a kind of an annoying appeal to, to a very Western conception. Like, well, how do I know if the tea is clean? I, like someone who's moving from drinking, a Yellow Label tea bag, which is not clean, to whole leaf Chinese tea. And how do I know if the tea is clean? Let me buy from this guy who's, who's American or European or whatever and says the tea is clean. That's, that's an issue.
The other thing that he was saying like, "Oh, I don't think the trees in Laos grow that big." Like, okay, well, we have people who are, who have been every year who definitely do, and trying to claim specific genetics off of tree size is a fool's errand, right? You don't know the introgression of Camellia Crassicolumna. You don't know the levels of seed-based genetic diffusion. You don't know the specific strains that are going on there. Yeah, sure, the Yiwu tree is, most of the trees producing somewhere one to three kilograms, but there are Dancong trees in Chaozhou producing like eight, nine plus kilograms, 10 plus kilograms, right? So this idea of a giant tree, wild tree introgression, any of this stuff, this idea of trying to draw a distinction like, oh, well, trees don't grow that big. Okay, well, some trees do. Like, what, what do you want us to say, guy? Like, you want us to believe you instead of our, our trusted sources, the people who we've been working with for years, the people who've lived there or on the ground? Like, what do you want me to say? Like, you're wrong? Do I have to go post a picture of a tree? Like,
[01:35:59] Pat Penny: This is the tree they showed us, which they did, of course, show us photos. Because every farmer, every processor has photos of themselves with the trees they're selling because it makes sense. Are, are we gonna have to worry about a day and age where it, is that an AI edited tree or not? Like-
[01:36:14] Jason Cohen: It's an AI edited tree. Now we gotta compose-
[01:36:15] Pat Penny: Not the case here
[01:36:15] Jason Cohen: ... the photo with us. A huge tree. Banyan, banyan sized tree. Me, you, and an elephant. Call it Jingmai. The elephants were here.
[01:36:25] Pat Penny: Look at how many kilograms this yielded. Hundreds. Hundreds. Okay, okay. So, I think that was a very specific comment, so I think we just wanna say that we, we would still have tea with this person and totally-
[01:36:36] Jason Cohen: Well, yeah,
[01:36:36] Pat Penny: more ... get to know them more. Yeah.
[01:36:38] Jason Cohen: Exactly. It's not, it's not specifically targeted at that. This happens repeatedly to us.
[01:36:44] Pat Penny: Yes. And, and with the how do we know we're right?
[01:36:47] Jason Cohen: And with how do we know that we're right is because we put in the work. We, we, we, we go to the places, we see it ourselves, we see the tea getting picked. Sometimes we process it ourselves. We commission the experiments and we, we don't have a financial interest in any of the outcomes. We're here, we're here to write about it.
[01:37:07] Pat Penny: Well, and I think we've already mentioned tonight, but we're, we're also happy to be wrong and to learn something, right? So, if there's a constructive argument to be made it- we're not gonna sit there and stand our ground when, something logically has got us to the conclusion that we weren't correct. We're, we're happy if someone can show us that we're wrong, 'cause that means we get to learn something new.
[01:37:26] Jason Cohen: Yeah. Hot takes. You have your hot takes?
[01:37:30] Pat Penny: I don't know how long we want this one. What's your most irrational tea opinion?
[01:37:36] Jason Cohen: Most irrational tea opinion. Wow. Oof. What's the most irrational tea opinion?
[01:37:43] Pat Penny: It's not a lightning round question, I guess.
[01:37:45] Jason Cohen: Oh my God. Well, that, that hit me like a ton of bricks. I think, I, I think it's something that we brought up already, like now I'm like eco-pilled and forest maxing and I see fields of things that I thought were good and now I, I question my own judgment.
Like being back in, in Hangzhou, being on Longjing in, in various Longjing producing villages and seeing just the fields and fields of green tea, which were like previously are considered beautiful. Everyone considers them beautiful. People go hiking there and drinking the green tea and being like, like, "This is like really heavily tended trees." Like these are, these, these trees have been stunted. These are like bonsai tea trees. I guess that's my most irrational-
[01:38:30] Pat Penny: And, and, and yet the tea is good, right? It's, it's very hard to reconcile.
[01:38:34] Jason Cohen: Yeah, it's hard to reconcile. That tea is good. And I guess my other irrational, irrational one is chenpi shou puer is great.
[01:38:42] Pat Penny: Yeah. I, I don't think it's irrational. I think most irrational tea opinion I think I would take boiled tea seven times out of 10 over gong fu. Like just a big old bowl of boiled like hei cha, like just wake up in the morning, have some boiled tea. Feeling, feeling a little under the weather, have some boiled tea. My soul calls for boiled tea.
[01:39:07] Jason Cohen: Interesting. Interesting.
[01:39:08] Pat Penny: Yeah. Yeah. And I don't know why. It's it's a deep, deep-seated spiritual thing. Not, not in the spiritually practicing way, but just like my body calls for boiled tea.
[01:39:17] Jason Cohen: Boil- boiled tea. Interesting. Interesting. I have this packet of unlabeled tea here. It's my handwriting.
[01:39:24] Pat Penny: Yeah.
[01:39:24] Jason Cohen: Unlabeled tea here that's boiled tea that if we had been hungover together I would've, I would've boiled for us.
[01:39:32] Pat Penny: I don't trust unlabeled packets from you, or even labeled packets from you. You gave me a box of various teas you no longer wanted to drink, and it really felt like you were just trying to get rid of your trash. 'Cause every, every, every time I'm tasting them now ... I mean, one was straight up poison, but the others so far have been uninspired. Unlabeled tea and/or not, not tea that we acquired together. I don't know, I don't know if I'm trusting it right now.
[01:39:58] Jason Cohen: Well, all the teas we drink together are great. So-
[01:40:01] Pat Penny: Yes,
[01:40:01] Jason Cohen:... I'm saying-
[01:40:02] Pat Penny: Yes, together ... When you let me, when you're sending me off with it.
[01:40:04] Jason Cohen: I'm gonna make it together. Yeah. I'm gonna make it together.
[01:40:05] Pat Penny: When you send me off with it.
[01:40:06] Jason Cohen: Okay. Okay, I'll make up for it. I'll make up for it. And then next, next gift bag of tea that I give you has to make up for this last one.
[01:40:14] Pat Penny: There we go. Okay. Most overrated tea. Go.
[01:40:20] Jason Cohen: Tieguanyin? I'm gonna go, I'm gonna go with Tieguanyin, I think, unless you say something smarter than that.
[01:40:30] Pat Penny: Tie- Tieguanyin is a great one because I feel like every time I get gifted tea from people who know nothing about tea, it's always Tieguanyin.
I, I, maybe for me, Silver Needle. I really feel like, no, no longer are we in the hype cycle of white tea. It was really more when we were first getting into tea, or I, I was first getting into tea, white tea had this real, like, hype premium-ness to it.
[01:40:50] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[01:40:50] Pat Penny: But to, to this day, I, I've got tons of white teas I like. I just don't feel like white tea when it's hyped up is ever as good as any other tea that's sold to me as something highly premium.
[01:41:01] Jason Cohen: Yeah. Maybe Fuding bai cha.
[01:41:05] Pat Penny: Yeah, I mean, I, I'll, I'll take, like, a Gong Mei or Shou Mei over, over a Yin Zhen any day.
[01:41:13] Jason Cohen: Yeah. I like the Yue Gong Bais, the gushu bai chas out of Yunnan.
[01:41:17] Pat Penny: Yunnan white tea in general I like a lot more than Fujian white tea. Yeah.
[01:41:21] Jason Cohen: Yeah, it's, it hits above its weight.
[01:41:22] Pat Penny: We, we both have, I think, the same one from person we had visited last year. Did you buy that, the 2020?
[01:41:28] Jason Cohen: I did. Yeah, yeah.
[01:41:29] Pat Penny: Okay, yeah. I mean, that, that tea is just so easy to go to. Once again, boiled, amazing. I had the flu or COVID two weeks ago. I actually missed out on seeing one of our listeners who when, when they visited Seattle, I was quite sick, and the first thing I go for is just boiled white tea from Yunnan.
The best.
[01:41:46] Jason Cohen: Amazing.
[01:41:47] Pat Penny: Yeah.
Okay. Next one. Let me see. One brewing habit everyone should stop doing right now.
[01:41:58] Jason Cohen: Is there one? Electric kettles.
[01:42:02] Pat Penny: As I go to brew my Yiwu tea with my electric kettle. They, they are lazy. I'm okay with being lazy, but yes.
[01:42:08] Jason Cohen: It's, it's all tetsubin or charcoal.
[01:42:10] Pat Penny: Can, can I think of a single time that the electric kettle helped me make a better cup of tea than a different brewing vessel? No. But is it damn convenient? Yes. I think everyone should stop using anything other than boiling water.
[01:42:23] Jason Cohen: I totally agree. 100% agree. Yeah. I keep telling people
[01:42:26] Pat Penny: Don't care.
[01:42:26] Jason Cohen: Boiling, boiling, boiling.
[01:42:27] Pat Penny: Boiling water. For Chinese tea.
[01:42:29] Jason Cohen: Yeah. Yeah. If it can't take boiling, it's not good tea.
[01:42:32] Pat Penny: Yep. Okay, this isn't a hot take just like question to tie things off. What are we, either you and me or the tea community at large collectively not paying enough attention to in tea?
[01:42:46] Jason Cohen: Climate change?
[01:42:49] Pat Penny: That, that's what I was thinking as well. Yeah. Talking about being eco pilled, like, yeah. All these teas we're talking about right now, like, we could be pretty, pretty screwed in the next decade, two decades.
[01:43:00] Jason Cohen: Yeah. What, what tea is being underrated, under, under thought of right now? It's a hard question. I don't know. There's lots of interesting things that are going on in various places. I've written some about the, the yancha and some of the hand processing that's going outside out of the Zhengyan or what most people don't consider the, the Zhengyan, the park up into the, the ecological area. Some truly amazing teas out of there. I think Dancong, being Dancong bro gets far too little attention in the West.
[01:43:37] Pat Penny: I, I think people can stop paying attention to Dancong. It's okay. You and I can just-
[01:43:41] Jason Cohen: Yeah.
[01:43:42] Pat Penny: ... get access to all the Dancong we want.
I mean, I would agree that that's definitely an area that people should pay more attention to, but yeah, my, my definitely number one answer is just climate change.
[01:43:51] Jason Cohen: Yeah. Climate change is the big problem in, in tea world right now.
[01:43:57] Pat Penny: Okay, that was gonna be the last question, but do we wanna end on something less sad?
[01:43:59] Jason Cohen: No, maybe something less dour .
[01:44:03] Pat Penny: I, I'll, I'll kick it over to you for a nice closer.
[01:44:06] Jason Cohen: Ah, for a nice closer. What are you looking forward to next year in China?
[01:44:14] Pat Penny: Well, next year, you, you will be living in China. So I'm looking forward to have a base of operations with you. I'm also really looking forward to you being better at Chinese, not that you're not... you, you get us around totally fine. There's no issues. I'm just excited for you to be able to converse at a higher level with our Chinese counterparts.
I'm excited to go somewhere that we haven't been before, so every year is kinda somewhere new. And I'm kinda just excited for like a new area. We're, we're planning of course, I think we've talked about it, we're planning Lincang. I guess my hope is that I will be more inspired from what we see in Lincang than what we saw in Menghai. I don't know how high my hopes are.
[01:44:54] Jason Cohen: Yeah, I think that'll, it'll be interesting to see. I think we're gonna wind up in like an outer region Lincang, is gonna be pretty different than, than like some core areas and then- I think we're gonna find a mix. I think that there's gonna be some good teas, but I think it's gonna be a mix.
[01:45:12] Pat Penny: Okay. Well, what are you excited about for next year and then we'll finish?
[01:45:15] Jason Cohen: Ooh. So-
[01:45:16] Pat Penny: Finishing the Yixing book?
[01:45:18] Jason Cohen: Finishing
[01:45:18] Pat Penny: Did you say that?
[01:45:18] Jason Cohen: ... the Yixing book.
[01:45:19] Pat Penny: Yeah.
[01:45:21] Jason Cohen: It's moving. It's moving. Just a couple hundred more pages. I think getting to follow the harvest. I'm gonna move down to Xishuangbanna through the entire harvest and literally just follow the harvest is the plan. I think that's hugely exciting. Just, yeah, just getting to, to soak it in and burn my forearms and...
[01:45:43] Pat Penny: Get bit by bugs and, yeah.
[01:45:46] Jason Cohen: Yeah. I'm gonna lose at least one toe to a snake. I mean-
[01:45:49] Pat Penny: Yeah ...
[01:45:50] Jason Cohen: the whole
[01:45:50] Pat Penny: Eat-
[01:45:50] Jason Cohen: ... the whole plan is there.
[01:45:52] Pat Penny: Eat some more dude dick. Yeah. All right.
[01:45:55] Jason Cohen: Amazing.
[01:45:55] Pat Penny: Well, I think that was a great AMA.
I just want to thank those who submitted questions. Of course thank those who are currently online with us. Hope you enjoyed. And to future listeners I hope you enjoy this conversation. Jason, the usual closing words.
[01:46:08] Jason Cohen: Well, thank you everyone for joining us in this edition of Tea Technique Editorial Conversations. This has been a wonderful AMA. Cheers.